New: a trial court in 1 of every 10 U.S. counties. Read the post
Court Rules
Judge

Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury

Individual Rules, Standing Orders & Policies

Los Angeles Superior Court

Limits & Logistics

Document Limits

IDC Statement
2 pgs

Courtesy Copies

Courtesy copies

  • Upon request
  • Upon Specific Request

Ex Parte Opposition

  • Day of Hearing

Exhibits

  • 1 copy • At Final Status Conference

IDC Statement

  • 1 copy • On Day of Filing
  • Upon Filing

Communication

Phone

Clerk, Other

(213) 830-0400
Technical Issues
Hours: 7:30 a.m. - 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday (except court holidays)
Phone
(818) 265-6422
Phone

Chambers

(818) 265-6423
Hours: 8:30 a.m. – Noon; 1:30 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.
Filters:

Page & Word Limits2 rules

Page LimitsMandatory

Five days before the IDC, each counsel shall file and serve an IDC statement no longer than 2 pages, without attachments, or a joint IDC statement no longer than 5 pages, without attachments (preferred).

Page limit
Up to 2 pages
Joint IDC statement
Up to 5 pages
Applies to
  • IDC statement
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 4
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters – C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences
Page LimitsMandatory

Individual IDC statements limited to 2 pages; joint IDC statements limited to 5 pages, both without attachments.

IDC statement for attorneys
Up to 2 pages
Joint IDC statement for attorneys
Up to 5 pages

Court's wording

Five days before the IDC, each counsel shall file and serve an IDC statement no longer than 2 pages, without attachments, or a joint IDC statement no longer than 5 pages, without attachments (preferred).

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 4
|SectionC. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

Document Format Requirements13 rules

FormattingMandatory

file a CMC statement on Judicial Council Form CM-110 within five (5) days of the hearing.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 3
|SectionA. Case Management Conferences
FormattingMandatory

The proposed jury instructions shall be prepared on Superior Court of Los Angeles County form SCLAC LACIV 129 or in a Word document that is in the same format.

File type
Word
Applies to
  • Proposed jury instructions
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 12
|SectionF. JURY INSTRUCTIONS
FormattingMandatory

Parties must attach copies of the designated transcript pages to the Joint Chart with numbered tabs separating each transcript, and all designated pages for each transcript must appear in page order behind a single tab.

Court's wording

The parties shall attach a copy of the pages of the transcripts of the deposition or former testimony they are designating or counter-designating to the Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony, with numbered tabs separating each deposition or trial transcript. For each transcript, all pages containing the designations and counter-designations shall be included in a single document in page order behind a single tab.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 13
|SectionH. Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony
FormattingMandatory

copies of all motions in limine, opposition papers, and reply papers, organized in one or more three-ring binders, tabbed in numerical order with the opposition papers and reply papers for each motion placed directly behind the moving papers with a colored sheet of paper separating the moving, opposition, and reply papers.

Binding
Tabbed three-ring binder
Applies to
  • Motion
  • Opposition
  • Reply

Formatting

  • Tabbed in numerical order
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|SectionTrial Preparation Order
FormattingMandatory

The parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to jointly prepare four sets of tabbed, internally paginated by document, and properly marked exhibits, organized numerically in three-ring binders (a set for the court, a set for the Judicial Assistant, and a set for the witnesses) (“Exhibit Binders”).

Binding
Tabbed three-ring binder
Applies to
  • Exhibits

Formatting

  • Internally paginated by document
  • Properly marked exhibits
  • Organized numerically
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section4. EXHIBIT BINDERS
FormattingImportant

Each designation and counter-designation shall be highlighted, with each party using a different color highlighter.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 13
|SectionH. Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony
FormattingImportant

Parties filing more than one motion in limine shall number them consecutively.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 14
|Section3. Motions in Limine
FormattingImportant

The parties' counsel and any self-represented parties shall mark all non-documentary exhibits and insert a simple written description of the exhibit behind the corresponding numerical tab in the Exhibit Binders.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section4. EXHIBIT BINDERS
FormattingImportant

The parties’ counsel and any self- represented parties shall also place the court’s yellow evidence tags (with only the case number and exhibit number filled in) on each exhibit in the Judicial Assistant’s copy of the Exhibit Binder.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section4. EXHIBIT BINDERS
FormattingImportant

a Trial Binder, consisting of one-sided, conformed copies, tabbed and organized in a three-ring binder with a table of contents

Binding
Tabbed three-ring binder
Applies to
  • Trial binder

Formatting

  • One-sided, conformed copies
  • Table of contents required
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section5. TRIAL BINDER
FormattingImportant

Copies of documentary exhibits shall be one-sided copies.

Applies to
  • Exhibits

Formatting

  • Copies of documentary exhibits must be one-sided
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section4. EXHIBIT BINDERS
FormattingImportant

(TYPE OR PRINT NAME) (SIGNATURE OF PARTY OR ATTORNEY)

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 25
|SectionSignature Lines
FormattingMandatory

Trial binders must be three-ring binders with tabs labeled A, B, C, D, F, G, H, I, J as specified.

Binding
Tabbed binder
Applies to
  • Trial binder

Formatting

  • Tab A: Trial Briefs
  • Tab B: Joint Witness List
  • Tab C: Joint Exhibit List
  • Tab G: Joint Verdict Form

Court's wording

By no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties are to submit to the Court a hard copy binder containing these previously filed documents under the following tabs: Tab A – Trial Briefs, Tab B – Joint Witness List, Tab C – Joint Exhibit List, Tab D – Joint Statement to Be Read to the Jury, Tab F – Full Text Jury Instructions (Joint and Contested), Tab G – Joint Verdict Form, Tab H – Joint Page and Line Designation for Deposition and Former Testimony, Tab I – Copies of the Current Operative Pleadings, Tab J – Motions in Limine (unless they are voluminous enough to merit their own binder).

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 5
|SectionIV. FINAL STATUS CONFERENCES

Document Filing Requirements31 rules

Filing RequirementsMandatory

The parties are to (1) meet and confer—in person or by telephone—no later than 30 days before the hearing, and (2) file a CMC statement on Judicial Council Form CM-110 within five (5) days of the hearing.

Document
CMC statement

Include

  • Judicial Council Form CM-110
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 3
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters – A. Case Management Conferences
Filing RequirementsMandatory

the notice must be included in the declaration and a proposed order must be presented with the moving papers.

Must include

  • Proposed order
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 5
|SectionD. Ex Parte Applications
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The notice must be included in the declaration and a proposed order must be presented with the moving papers.

Must include

  • Proposed order
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 5
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Parties who do not provide a court reporter for trial are directed to meet at the close of each session and prepare a joint statement of the witness testimony presented that day. The joint statement must be lodged with the Court the next morning before proceedings resume. No exceptions.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 6
|SectionV. Trials — B. Court Reporter
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The joint witness list must contain seven specified columns (witness name/expert status/accommodations, calling party, expected testimony, direct/cross/total time estimates in hours) plus a grand total, and any witness not listed is subject to being excluded.

Court's wording

The joint witness list shall be organized with columns (in the format set forth below) which state (1) the name of each witness (in alphabetical order), if the witness is being called to testify as an expert, and any special requirements or accommodations needed for the witness (e.g., interpreter), (2) the party calling the witness, (3) whether the witness is actually expected to testify, (4) a brief description of the witness’s expected testimony, (5) an estimate of the length of direct examination (in hours), (6) an estimate of the length of cross- examination (in hours), and (7) the total estimated length of examination (in hours). At the end of the joint witness list, the parties and any self-represented parties shall add up the estimated times for all witnesses’ testimony and state the grand total in the last column. Any witness who is not included on the joint witness list is subject to being excluded from

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 10
|Section2.B. JOINT WITNESS LIST
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Each party shall file a trial brief succinctly identifying: (1) the claims and defenses that remain in dispute for trial; (2) the major legal issues (with supporting points and authorities); (3) the relief and calculation of damages sought; and (4) any other information that may assist the court at trial.

Document
Trial brief

Must include

  • Legal argument
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 10
|Section2.A. TRIAL BRIEFS
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to prepare and file a joint list of all witnesses whom any party intends to call at trial, excluding impeachment and rebuttal witnesses.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 10
|Section2.B. JOINT WITNESS LIST
Filing RequirementsMandatory

For jury trials, the parties must jointly prepare and file a brief written statement of the case for the court to read to the jury.

Court's wording

For jury trials, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to prepare and file a brief, joint written statement of the case for the court to read to the jury. (Local Rule 3.25, subd. (g)(4).)

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 11
|SectionD. JOINT STATEMENT TO BE READ TO THE JURY
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Counsel and self-represented parties must jointly prepare and file an exhibit list stating eight specified items for each trial exhibit and must meet and confer to resolve authenticity and admissibility objections.

Court's wording

The parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to prepare and file a joint exhibit list organized with columns (in the format set forth below) which state, as to each exhibit any party intends to offer at trial: (1) the exhibit number, (2) a brief description of the exhibit, (3) which party is offering the exhibit, (4) whether the parties have stipulated to authentication of the exhibit, (5) whether the parties have stipulated to admissibility of the exhibit, (6) any evidentiary objections to admission of the exhibit, (7) the date the exhibit was marked for identification, and (8) the date the exhibit was admitted into evidence. (Local Rule 3.25, subd. (g)(6).) As set forth above, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall meet and confer in an effort to resolve objections to the authenticity and admissibility of each exhibit.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 11
|SectionC. JOINT EXHIBIT LIST
Filing RequirementsMandatory

For jury trials, the parties must jointly prepare a complete set of full-text proposed jury instructions, editing CACI instructions, inserting party names, and removing blanks and irrelevant material.

Court's wording

For jury trials, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to prepare a complete set of full text proposed jury instructions, editing all proposed Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (“CACI”) instructions, inserting party names, and eliminating blanks and other irrelevant or inapplicable material.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 12
|SectionF. JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Filing RequirementsMandatory

For jury trials, the parties must jointly prepare and file a list of proposed jury instructions stating six specified items for each instruction.

Court's wording

For jury trials, the parties' counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to prepare and file a joint list of proposed jury instructions (in the format set forth below) which states, as to each proposed jury instruction: (1) the jury instruction number (listed in numerical order), (2) the title of the jury instruction, (3) the party requesting the jury instruction, (4) whether the jury instruction is agreed upon or contested, (5) a concise statement of any objection, and (6) whether the jury instruction was given by the court ("Joint List of Proposed Jury Instructions").

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 12
|SectionTRIAL PREPARATION ORDER (JOINT AND CONTESTED)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

For jury trials, parties must jointly file a proposed verdict form acceptable to all parties, or, if they cannot agree, each party must separately file a proposed verdict form.

Court's wording

For jury trials, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall work together to prepare and file a joint proposed general verdict form or a joint proposed special verdict form acceptable to all parties. (Local Rule 3.25, subd. (g)(8).) If the parties cannot agree on a joint verdict form, each party must separately file a proposed verdict form.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 12
|SectionG. VERDICT FORM(S)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Parties intending to use deposition or former trial testimony must meet and confer and jointly prepare and file a Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations.

Court's wording

If any parties intend to use deposition testimony or former trial testimony in lieu of or in addition to a witness’s live testimony, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall meet and confer to discuss, and work together to prepare and file, a joint chart in the format set forth below (“Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony”).

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 13
|SectionH. Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Motions in limine must be accompanied by declarations that comply with Los Angeles County Court Rule 3.57(a).

Court's wording

The parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall comply with the statutory notice provisions of Code of Civil Procedure section 1005 and file declarations that comply with the requirements of Los Angeles County Court Rule 3.57, subdivision (a).

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 14
|Section3. Motions in Limine
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Plaintiff and defendant shall serve verification with the documents they produce.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 19
|Section2. Production of Documents
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The list provided by defendant may be in the chart or spreadsheet format, and shall include the VIN, date of repair visit, dealership or other reporting location, and text of the other customers' reported complaint, but shall not include the other customers' names, addresses, phone numbers, e-mail addresses, or other personal identifying information.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 19
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Plaintiff and defendant shall serve verification with the documents they produce.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 19
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters
Filing RequirementsMandatory

You are ordered to meet and confer in person or by telephone and to respond to the following questions, stating your respective positions.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 21
|SectionMotor Vehicle Personal Injury Cases - Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum
Filing RequirementsMandatory

l am completely familiar with this case and will be fully prepared to discuss the status of discovery and alternative dispute resolution, as well as other issues raised by this addendum, and will possess the authority to enter into stipulations on these issues at the time of the initial case management conference, including the written authority of the party where required.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 25
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters - A. Case Management Conferences (Addendum)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

(TYPE OR PRINT NAME) (SIGNATURE OF PARTY OR ATTORNEY)

Placement
Signature block
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 25
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters - A. Case Management Conferences (Addendum)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum must include a statement that the signer is familiar with the case and has authority to enter into stipulations.

Court's wording

l am completely familiar with this case and will be fully prepared to discuss the status of discovery and alternative dispute resolution, as well as other issues raised by this addendum, and will possess the authority to enter into stipulations on these issues at the time of the initial case management conference, including the written authority of the party where required.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 25
|SectionSigner Attestation
Filing RequirementsImportant

If all defendants have not been served, plaintiff or plaintiff’s counsel must submit a declaration to the court five (5) days prior to the hearing explaining what efforts have been undertaken to accomplish service.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 3
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters – A. Case Management Conferences
Filing RequirementsImportant

If there is an appropriate CACI jury instruction on a point of law, the court expects the parties to request the CACI instruction instead of a specially prepared jury instruction.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 12
|SectionF. JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Filing RequirementsImportant

The Joint Chart must include specified columns for both designations (witness name/number, date and type of testimony, page/line designations, objections, counter-designation info, and court ruling) and counter-designations (witness name/number, date and type of testimony, page/line counter-designations, objections, related designation number, and court ruling).

Court's wording

In the joint chart, each designating party's designations of deposition or former testimony shall include columns which state: (1) the designation number and name of the witness, (2) the date and type of testimony (e.g., deposition or trial testimony), (3) the page and line designations of the deposition or former testimony requested to be used, (4) any objections, (5) whether the other party has counter-designated any additional deposition or former testimony of the witness that relates to the designation, and, if so, the designation number of the counter-designation, and (6) the court's ruling. In the joint chart, each counter-designating party's counter-designations of additional deposition or former testimony of the witness that relates to the designations shall include columns which state: (1) the designation number and name of the witness, (2) the date and type of testimony (e.g., deposition or trial testimony), (3) the page and line counter-designations of the deposition or former testimony requested to be used, (4) any objections, (5) the designation number of the other party's designation to which the counter-designation relates, and (6) the court's ruling.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 13
|SectionH. Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony
Filing RequirementsImportant

there is an appropriate CACI special verdict form for a cause of action, affirmative defense, or other finding, the court expects the parties to use the CACI special verdict form.

Document
Special verdict form

Include

  • CACI special verdict form
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 13
|SectionTrial Preparation Order
Filing RequirementsImportant

Parties filing opposition and reply papers shall identify the corresponding motion number in the caption of their papers.

Document
Motion in limine opposition and reply papers
Placement
Caption

Must include

  • Corresponding motion number
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 14
|Section3. Motions in Limine
Filing RequirementsImportant

The caption of each motion in limine shall concisely identify the evidence that the moving party seeks to exclude.

Document
Motion in limine
Placement
Caption
Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 14
|Section3. Motions in Limine
Filing RequirementsImportant

(for trials by the court without a jury, the Trial Binder shall include only the documents listed under Tabs A, B, C, H, and I with the other sections left empty):

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section5. TRIAL BINDER
Filing RequirementsImportant

The parties shall organize proposed jury instructions into groups behind Tab F in the following order (labeled by cover sheets): (1) the agreed-upon instructions, (2) plaintiff’s requested instructions to which defendant objects, and (3) defendant’s requested instructions to which plaintiff objects.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 16
|Section5. TRIAL BINDER
Filing RequirementsImportant

d. If so, what is the basis for the claim? e. Is there a claim for per se negligence? f. Is there a claim for violations of the vehicle code? g. If so, what section of the vehicle code? h. Will the defendant admit liability? i. Are there any criminal charges pending or contemplated? j. Is there a criminal investigation on-going?

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 25
|SectionIII. Pretrial Matters - A. Case Management Conferences (Addendum)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The Trial Binder must contain tabbed sections for Trial Briefs, Joint Witness List, Joint Exhibit List, Joint Statement to the Jury, Jury Instructions, Verdict Forms, Deposition Designation Chart, Operative Pleadings, and Motions in Limine (unless too voluminous for the binder).

Court's wording

Tab A: Trial Briefs Tab B: Joint Witness List Tab C: Joint Exhibit List Tab D: Joint Statement to Be Read to the Jury Tab F: Joint and Contested Jury Instructions Tab G: Joint or Contested Verdict Form(s) Tab H: Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations for Deposition and Former Testimony Tab I: Copies of the Current Operative Pleadings (including the operative complaint, answer, cross-complaint, if any, and answer to any cross-complaint). Tab J: Motions in Limine, unless they are too voluminous and require their own binder.

Ca Lasc Courtroom GLN E · p. 15
|Section5. TRIAL BINDER

Filing & Service rules

Electronic Filing Rules

Attorneys must e-file ex parte applications by 10 a.m. court day prior to hearing; pro se litigants may file in person on day of hearing.

Ex parte applications must be e-filed and noticed no later than 10 a.m. the court day prior to the hearing. Self-represented litigants must still give proper notice but may file their ex parte application at 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing in the Clerk’s Office on the first floor, Room 102.

Page 5 | D. Ex Parte Applications

Ex parte applications must be e-filed and noticed no later than 10 a.m. the court day before the hearing.

Ex parte applications must be e-filed and noticed no later than 10 a.m. the court day prior to the hearing.

Page 5 | III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

Parties must electronically file the trial preparation documents (trial briefs, joint lists, jury instructions, verdict form, deposition designations, pleadings, and motions in limine) no later than 5 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

As set forth in more detail in the Trial Preparation Order, no later than 5 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties must electronically file the documents listed below.

Page 5 | IV. Final Status Conferences

All trial documents are to be filed pursuant to the General Order re Mandatory Electronic Filing for Civil dated November 5, 2018.

All trial documents are to be filed pursuant to the General Order re Mandatory Electronic Filing for Civil dated November 5, 2018.

Page 10 | 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

Attorneys must e-file trial documents per 2018 Mandatory E-Filing Order; self-represented litigants are exempt.

All trial documents are to be filed pursuant to the General Order re Mandatory Electronic Filing for Civil dated November 5, 2018. Pursuant to California Rules of Court, Rule 2.253 (b)(2), self-represented litigants are exempt from the mandatory electronic filing requirement.

Page 10 | 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

Self-represented litigants may file their ex parte application in paper at the Clerk's Office (Room 102) at 8:30 a.m. on the hearing day, but must still give proper notice.

Self-represented litigants must still give proper notice but may file their ex parte application at 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing in the Clerk's Office on the first floor, Room 102.

Page 5 | III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

Self-represented litigants are exempt from the mandatory electronic filing requirement under California Rules of Court, Rule 2.253(b)(2).

Pursuant to California Rules of Court, Rule 2.253 (b)(2), self-represented litigants are exempt from the mandatory electronic filing requirement.

Page 10 | 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

Filing Timing and Cure Windows

The CMC statement must be filed within five (5) days of the case management conference hearing.

The parties are to (1) meet and confer—in person or by telephone—no later than 30 days before the hearing, and (2) file a CMC statement on Judicial Council Form CM-110 within five (5) days of the hearing.

Page 3 | III. Pretrial Matters – A. Case Management Conferences

IDC statements must be filed and served five days before the Informal Discovery Conference.

Five days before the IDC, each counsel shall file and serve an IDC statement no longer than 2 pages, without attachments, or a joint IDC statement no longer than 5 pages, without attachments (preferred).

Page 4 | III. Pretrial Matters – C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

Oppositions to ex parte applications must be e-filed no later than 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing.

Oppositions must be e-filed no later than 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing and courtesy copies are required directly in the courtroom.

Page 5 | III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

The hard copy trial binder must be submitted to the Court no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

By no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties are to submit to the Court a hard copy binder containing these previously filed documents under the following tabs:

Page 5 | IV. Final Status Conferences

Ex parte applications must be e-filed by 10 a.m. the court day prior to the hearing.

Ex parte applications must be e-filed and noticed no later than 10 a.m. the court day prior to the hearing.

Page 5 | D. Ex Parte Applications

Ex parte oppositions must be e-filed by 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing.

Oppositions must be e-filed no later than 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing and courtesy copies are required directly in the courtroom.

Page 5 | D. Ex Parte Applications

The filing and notice deadline for ex parte applications is 10 a.m. on the court day prior to the hearing.

Ex parte applications must be e-filed and noticed no later than 10 a.m. the court day prior to the hearing.

Page 5 | III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

The deadline to electronically file the FSC trial preparation documents is 5 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

As set forth in more detail in the Trial Preparation Order, no later than 5 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties must electronically file the documents listed below.

Page 5 | IV. Final Status Conferences

Deposition transcripts and discovery responses must be lodged with the Court before trial begins.

Prior to the commencement of the trial, deposition transcripts and discovery responses shall be lodged with the Court (SCLAC Local Rule 3.56).

Page 7 | H. Use of Deposition Transcripts and Discovery Responses

Trial documents must be filed no later than five calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

No later than five calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall file and serve the following documents:

Page 10 | 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

Trial documents must be filed and served no later than 5 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

No later than five calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall file and serve the following documents:

Page 10 | 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

If the motions in limine are too voluminous to fit behind Tab J in the Trial Binder, the parties must submit a separate motion in limine no later than three calendar days before the

If the motions in limine are too voluminous to fit behind Tab J in the Trial Binder, the parties must submit a separate motion in limine no later than three calendar days before the

Page 14 | 3. Motions in Limine

The Trial Binder must be jointly prepared and lodged in Department E no later than three calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

No later than three calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall jointly prepare and lodge in Department E a Trial Binder, consisting of one-sided, conformed copies, tabbed and organized in a three-ring binder with a table of contents that includes the following

Page 15 | 5. TRIAL BINDER

Plaintiff must file the completed Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum no later than 5 court days before the Initial Case Management Conference.

Plaintiff is responsible for filing the completed Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum no later than five (5) court days before the date set for the Initial Case Management Conference.

Page 21 | Motor Vehicle Personal Injury Cases - Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum

Plaintiff must file completed Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum no later than 5 court days before the Initial Case Management Conference.

Plaintiff is responsible for filing the completed Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum no later than five (5) court days before the date set for the Initial Case Management Conference. (See California Rules of Court, Rules 3.724, 3.725.)

Page 21 | Motor Vehicle Personal Injury Cases Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum

The declaration explaining service efforts must be submitted to the court five (5) days prior to the case management conference hearing.

If all defendants have not been served, plaintiff or plaintiff’s counsel must submit a declaration to the court five (5) days prior to the hearing explaining what efforts have been undertaken to accomplish service.

Page 3 | III. Pretrial Matters – A. Case Management Conferences

Service and Proof of Service Rules

All defendants must be served with the complaint by the case management conference.

All defendants must be served with the complaint by the case management conference.

Page 3 | III. Pretrial Matters – A. Case Management Conferences

PowerPoint slides must be provided to opposing counsel before the presentation, leaving sufficient time to object.

If a PowerPoint is to be used, a copy of the slides must be shared with the opposing counsel prior to the presentation leaving sufficient time to object.

Page 7 | F. Display of Demonstrative Evidence

Before reading deposition, interrogatory, or request-for-admission material into evidence, the party must notify the Court and opposing party of the specific page/line or numbers to be used.

Before reading into evidence any portion of a deposition, interrogatory, or request for admission, the party shall advise the Court and opposing party of the page and line number of the deposition, or the numbers of the interrogatories or requests for admission to be read or shown to the witness (SCLAC Local Rule 3.158).

Page 7 | H. Use of Deposition Transcripts and Discovery Responses

Visual aids or graphic devices intended for closing argument must be shown to the opposing party before closing argument.

The parties are reminded that any visual aids or graphic devices a party intends to use during closing argument must be shown to the opposing party before the closing argument. (Super. Ct. L.A. County, Local Rules, rule 3.180.)

Page 8 | L. Closing Arguments and Jury Instruction

Parties' counsel and self-represented parties must exchange all trial exhibits no later than 18 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

No later than 18 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall exchange all exhibits they intend to introduce at trial.

Page 9 | 1. MEET AND CONFER

Trial documents must be served no later than five calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

No later than five calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall file and serve the following documents:

Page 10 | 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

Motions in limine must comply with the statutory notice provisions of Code of Civil Procedure section 1005.

The parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall comply with the statutory notice provisions of Code of Civil Procedure section 1005 and file declarations that comply with the requirements of Los Angeles County Court Rule 3.57, subdivision (a).

Page 14 | 3. Motions in Limine

In Song-Beverly cases, parties must exchange specified documents within 60 days of service of the CMC Order.

Within 60 days of service of this Order both plaintiff and defendant shall provide copies of the following documents, which are in their respective possession, custody and/or control, to the opposing side(s):

Page 18 | 2. Production of Documents

Plaintiff's attorney must serve this Order and the attached Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum on all defense attorneys upon service of the Summons and Complaint.

Plaintiff's attorney is ordered to provide service of this Order and the attached Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum to all defense attorneys upon service of the Summons and the Complaint.

Page 20 | III. Pretrial Matters

The Motor Vehicle Personal Injury Case Addendum to the Case Management Conference Statement must be served on all parties/attorneys of record concurrently with the Notice of Case Management Conference.

You are ordered to serve this Motor Vehicle Personal Injury Case Addendum to Case Management Conference Statement on all parties/attorneys of record concurrently with the Notice of Case Management Conference.

Page 21 | Motor Vehicle Personal Injury Cases - Joint Case Management Conference Statement Addendum

Discovery documents may be provided as PDF electronically at the producing party's option.

The information may be provided to the opposing party in electronic form as a PDF at the option of the producing party.

Page 19 | 2. Production of Documents

Discovery information produced under the Order may, at the producing party's option, be provided to the opposing party electronically as a PDF.

The information may be provided to the opposing party in electronic form as a PDF at the option of the producing party.

Page 19 | III. Pretrial Matters

Filing Fees and Waivers

Jury fees must be paid daily, with the daily rate provided by the judicial assistant.

Jury fees must be paid on a daily basis. The judicial assistant will advise of the daily rate.

Page 6 | V. Trials — C. Jury Fees

Jury fees must be paid daily; judicial assistant provides the daily rate.

Jury fees must be paid on a daily basis. The judicial assistant will advise of the daily rate.

Page 6 | C. Jury Fees

A party with a fee waiver may request an official court reporter by filing form SCLAC LACIV 269 before the hearing or trial, while a party without a fee waiver may arrange a certified shorthand reporter to serve as official pro tempore reporter.

A party who has received a fee waiver may request an official court reporter by filing form SCLAC LACIV 269 before the hearing or trial. A party who has not received a fee waiver may arrange for the presence of a certified shorthand reporter to serve as official pro tempore reporter.

Page 3 | Court Reporters

Courtesy Copy Requirements

Courtesy copies are not required unless specifically requested, except for IDC statements and ex parte oppositions.

The Court does not require courtesy copies of filed documents unless it makes a specific request. The only exceptions are Informal Discovery Conference Statements and ex parte oppositions, as explained below.

Page 2 | B. Courtesy Copies

Courtesy copies of filed documents are not required unless the Court specifically requests them, except for Informal Discovery Conference Statements and ex parte oppositions.

The Court does not require courtesy copies of filed documents unless it makes a specific request. The only exceptions are Informal Discovery Conference Statements and ex parte oppositions, as explained below.

Page 2 | B. Courtesy Copies

Parties must provide the Court with hard-copy courtesy copies of the IDC statement on the day of filing.

The parties shall provide the Court with hard-copy courtesy copies of the IDC statement on the day of filing.

Page 4 | III. Pretrial Matters – C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

Hard-copy courtesy copies of IDC statements must be provided to the Court on the day of filing.

The parties shall provide the Court with hard-copy courtesy copies of the IDC statement on the day of filing.

Page 4 | C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

Ex parte oppositions require courtesy copies delivered to the courtroom by the day of the hearing.

Oppositions must be e-filed no later than 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing and courtesy copies are required directly in the courtroom.

Page 5 | D. Ex Parte Applications

Courtesy copies of ex parte oppositions are required directly in the courtroom.

Oppositions must be e-filed no later than 8:30 a.m. on the day of the hearing and courtesy copies are required directly in the courtroom.

Page 5 | III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

One set of the Exhibit Binders must be brought to the Final Status Conference for the court to review.

The parties’ counsel and any self-represented parties shall bring one set of the Exhibit Binders to the Final Status Conference for the court to review.

Page 15 | 4. EXHIBIT BINDERS

Sealing & Redaction Procedures

A party seeking protection for the ordered discovery information must serve and file a proposed protective order within 5 days of the Order, and the parties must meet and confer on language, with the SCLAC standard Protective Order as the default.

If a party believes any of this information should be subject to a protective order, that party shall serve ad file a proposed protective order within 5 days of this Order and the parties shall meet and confer as to agreeable language for the same. The default will be the standard Protective Order provided by the SCLAC in its website.

Page 19 | III. Pretrial Matters

Filing Bundling Requirements

Parties must submit a hard copy trial binder of the previously e-filed documents, organized under designated tabs A through J, no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

By no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties are to submit to the Court a hard copy binder containing these previously filed documents under the following tabs:

Page 5 | IV. Final Status Conferences

Voluminous motions in limine must be submitted in separate three-ring binders tabbed numerically, with opposition/reply papers behind each motion separated by colored paper, due 3 calendar days before FSC.

If the motions in limine are too voluminous to fit behind Tab J in the Trial Binder, the parties must submit a separate motion in limine binder no later than three calendar days before the Final Status Conference, consisting of copies of all motions in limine, opposition papers, and reply papers, organized in one or more three-ring binders, tabbed in numerical order with the opposition papers and reply papers for each motion placed directly behind the moving papers with a colored sheet of paper separating the moving, opposition, and reply papers.

Page 14 | 3. MOTIONS IN LIMINE

Hard copy trial binder with specified tabs must be submitted to the Court no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

By no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties are to submit to the Court a hard copy binder containing these previously filed documents under the following tabs: Tab A – Trial Briefs, Tab B – Joint Witness List, Tab C – Joint Exhibit List, Tab D – Joint Statement to Be Read to the Jury, Tab F – Full Text Jury Instructions (Joint and Contested), Tab G – Joint Verdict Form, Tab H – Joint Page and Line Designation for Deposition and Former Testimony, Tab I – Copies of the Current Operative Pleadings, Tab J – Motions in Limine (unless they are voluminous enough to merit their own binder).

Page 5 | IV. FINAL STATUS CONFERENCES

Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

The parties must first meet and confer in person, by video conference, or by telephone call to attempt to informally resolve all discovery issues. If the parties cannot agree, the Court requests that the parties schedule an Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) with the Courtroom Assistant and participate in the IDC before filing any discovery motion.

The parties must first meet and confer in person, by video conference, or by telephone call to attempt to informally resolve all discovery issues. If the parties cannot agree, the Court requests that the parties schedule an Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) with the Courtroom Assistant and participate in the IDC before filing any discovery motion.

Page 4 | III. Pretrial Matters – C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

Parties must obtain and schedule a motion hearing date through the online Court Reservation System (CRS) on the Superior Court of Los Angeles County website.

Parties must obtain and schedule a motion hearing date via the online Court Reservation System (CRS) on the Superior Court of Los Angeles County website: “Online Services” tab.

Page 4 | III. Pretrial Matters – B. Law And Motion

Parties must meet and confer no later than 11 calendar days before the Final Status Conference to prepare required trial documents and binders, attempt stipulations on exhibit authenticity/admissibility and motions in limine, and discuss settlement.

No later than 11 calendar days before the Final Status Conference, the parties' counsel and any self-represented parties shall meet and confer to do the following: (1) discuss and prepare the documents required in Sections 2.B-H below, and the Motions in Limine Binder, Exhibit Binders, and Trial Binder required in Sections 3-5 below, (2) discuss and make a good faith effort to stipulate to the authenticity and admissibility of each trial exhibit, (3) discuss and make a good faith effort to stipulate to resolve each motion in limine, (4) discuss and make a good faith effort to settle the case.

Page 9 | 1. MEET AND CONFER

Motions in limine must be noticed for hearing at the Final Status Conference.

Motions in limine shall be noticed for hearing at the Final Status Conference.

Page 14 | 3. Motions in Limine

Chambers Communication Rules

The Department E courtroom can be reached by telephone at (818) 265-6423 during courtroom hours of 8:30 a.m.-Noon and 1:30 p.m.-4:30 p.m.

TELEPHONE NUMBER: (818) 265-6423 COURTROOM HOURS: 8:30 a.m. – Noon 1:30 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.

Page 1 | Courtroom Information

Courtroom phone number is (818) 265-6423, available during 8:30 a.m.–Noon and 1:30 p.m.–4:30 p.m.

TELEPHONE NUMBER: (818) 265-6423 COURTROOM HOURS: 8:30 a.m. – Noon 1:30 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.

Page 2 | COURTROOM INFORMATION

If both parties agree to submit on the tentative ruling, they may notify the Court by phone at (818) 265-6422, though if the other party does not agree, the Court may proceed with the hearing and issue a ruling different from the tentative.

If both parties agree to submit on the tentative, you may let the Court know by calling the Court at (818) 265-6422.

Page 4 | III. Pretrial Matters – B. Law And Motion

Parties agreeing to submit on tentative ruling may notify the Court by calling (818) 265-6422.

If both parties agree to submit on the tentative, you may let the Court know by calling the Court at (818) 265-6422.

Page 4 | B. Law And Motion

LACourtConnect technical support available at (213) 830-0400, 7:30 a.m.–5:30 p.m. Monday-Friday (except holidays).

there is a dedicated Service Desk for LACourtConnect users. The Service Desk is available at (213) 830-0400, Monday through Friday (except court holidays), between 7:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m.

Page 2 | A. Court Appearances

LACourtConnect technical issues should be resolved using the LACourtConnect website resources or the dedicated Service Desk at (213) 830-0400, available weekdays 7:30 a.m.-5:30 p.m. (excluding court holidays), and attorneys should do so before the appearance day.

If you are having difficulties turning on your video camera while using LACourtConnect, please visit https://my.lacourt.org/laccwelcome, where you will find tutorials, instructions, and downloads. Also, please be advised that there is a dedicated Service Desk for LACourtConnect users. The Service Desk is available at (213) 830-0400, Monday through Friday (except court holidays), between 7:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. Attorneys are strongly advised to consult these resources before the day of an appearance.

Page 2 | A. Court Appearances

Documents of departments with no single judge listed

About Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury

Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury sits on the Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles, the state trial court serving Los Angeles County.

Judge Chowdhury's procedures are published through the court's general rules.

Common questions about Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury's rules

Are courtesy copies required for Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

Courtesy-copy rule applies for IDC statements. Details: delivery upon filing. Parties must provide the Court with hard-copy courtesy copies of the IDC statement on the day of filing.

View ruleSource: page 4, section III. Pretrial Matters – C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

Does Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?

Parties must obtain and schedule a motion hearing date through the online Court Reservation System (CRS) on the Superior Court of Los Angeles County website.

View ruleSource: page 4, section III. Pretrial Matters – B. Law And Motion

What page or word limits apply to IDC statement before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury's rule states these limits: 2 pages; 5 pages. Excludes attachments. Individual IDC statements are limited to 2 pages and joint IDC statements to 5 pages (preferred), both filed without attachments.

View ruleSource: page 4, section III. Pretrial Matters – C. Discovery Motions—Informal Discovery Conferences

What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury's formatting rule includes file format docx and may alternatively be prepared on superior court of los angeles county form sclac laciv 129 in the same format. Proposed jury instructions must be prepared on Los Angeles Superior Court form SCLAC LACIV 129 or in a Word document in the same format.

View ruleSource: page 12, section F. JURY INSTRUCTIONS

What must be included with ex parte application filings before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

The rule requires proposed order. Ex parte applications must include the notice in the declaration and present a proposed order with the moving papers.

View ruleSource: page 5, section III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

What must be included with joint statement of witness testimony filings before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

Parties without a court reporter must prepare a joint statement of each day's witness testimony at the close of the session and lodge it with the Court the next morning before proceedings resume — no exceptions.

View ruleSource: page 6, section V. Trials — B. Court Reporter

How may parties contact Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury's chambers?

The rule lists phone (213) 830-0400. LACourtConnect technical issues should be resolved using the LACourtConnect website resources or the dedicated Service Desk at (213) 830-0400, available weekdays 7:30 a.m.-5:30 p.m. (excluding court holidays), and attorneys should do so before the appearance day.

View ruleSource: page 2, section A. Court Appearances

How does Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury handle sealed or redacted filings?

A party seeking protection for the ordered discovery information must serve and file a proposed protective order within 5 days of the Order, and the parties must meet and confer on language, with the SCLAC standard Protective Order as the default.

View ruleSource: page 19, section III. Pretrial Matters

Does Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury require motion papers to be bundled?

Parties must submit a hard copy trial binder of the previously e-filed documents, organized under designated tabs A through J, no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

View ruleSource: page 5, section IV. Final Status Conferences

Is electronic filing required before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. All trial documents are to be filed pursuant to the General Order re Mandatory Electronic Filing for Civil dated November 5, 2018.

View ruleSource: page 10, section 2. TRIAL DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED

Are filing fees or waivers addressed before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

A fee is required for covered filings. Jury fees must be paid daily; judicial assistant provides the daily rate.

View ruleSource: page 6, section C. Jury Fees

When is a filing treated as filed before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

The rule states a 10:00 AM filing cutoff. The filing and notice deadline for ex parte applications is 10 a.m. on the court day prior to the hearing.

View ruleSource: page 5, section III. Pretrial Matters — D. Ex Parte Applications

What rule applies to service for complaint before Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury?

Details: recipient: the opposing party. All defendants must be served with the complaint by the case management conference.

View ruleSource: page 3, section III. Pretrial Matters – A. Case Management Conferences
Complete rules summary for Judge Ashfaq G. Chowdhury

LACourtConnect technical issues should be resolved using the LACourtConnect website resources or the dedicated Service Desk at (213) 830-0400, available weekdays 7:30 a.m.-5:30 p.m. (excluding court holidays), and attorneys should do so before the appearance day.

If both parties agree to submit on the tentative ruling, they may notify the Court by phone at (818) 265-6422, though if the other party does not agree, the Court may proceed with the hearing and issue a ruling different from the tentative.

All defendants must be served with the complaint by the case management conference.

The declaration explaining service efforts must be submitted to the court five (5) days prior to the case management conference hearing.

Parties must obtain and schedule a motion hearing date through the online Court Reservation System (CRS) on the Superior Court of Los Angeles County website.

Parties must provide the Court with hard-copy courtesy copies of the IDC statement on the day of filing.

The parties must first meet and confer in person, by video conference, or by telephone call to attempt to informally resolve all discovery issues. If the parties cannot agree, the Court requests that the parties schedule an Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) with the Courtroom Assistant and participate in the IDC before filing any discovery motion.

Courtesy copies of ex parte oppositions are required directly in the courtroom.

Self-represented litigants may file their ex parte application in paper at the Clerk's Office (Room 102) at 8:30 a.m. on the hearing day, but must still give proper notice.

The filing and notice deadline for ex parte applications is 10 a.m. on the court day prior to the hearing.

Ex parte applications must include the notice in the declaration and present a proposed order with the moving papers.

Parties without a court reporter must prepare a joint statement of each day's witness testimony at the close of the session and lodge it with the Court the next morning before proceedings resume — no exceptions.

Parties must submit a hard copy trial binder of the previously e-filed documents, organized under designated tabs A through J, no later than 3 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

The deadline to electronically file the FSC trial preparation documents is 5 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

PowerPoint slides must be provided to opposing counsel before the presentation, leaving sufficient time to object.

Deposition transcripts and discovery responses must be lodged with the Court before trial begins.

Before reading deposition, interrogatory, or request-for-admission material into evidence, the party must notify the Court and opposing party of the specific page/line or numbers to be used.

Parties must meet and confer no later than 11 calendar days before the Final Status Conference to prepare required trial documents and binders, attempt stipulations on exhibit authenticity/admissibility and motions in limine, and discuss settlement.

Self-represented litigants are exempt from the mandatory electronic filing requirement under California Rules of Court, Rule 2.253(b)(2).

Parties' counsel and self-represented parties must exchange all trial exhibits no later than 18 calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

Trial documents must be served no later than five calendar days before the Final Status Conference.

Parties' counsel and self-represented parties must jointly prepare and file a list of all trial witnesses, excluding impeachment and rebuttal witnesses (Local Rule 3.25(g)(5)).

Proposed jury instructions must be prepared on Los Angeles Superior Court form SCLAC LACIV 129 or in a Word document in the same format.

For jury trials, the parties must jointly prepare and file a brief written statement of the case for the court to read to the jury.

The Joint Chart must include specified columns for both designations (witness name/number, date and type of testimony, page/line designations, objections, counter-designation info, and court ruling) and counter-designations (witness name/number, date and type of testimony, page/line counter-designations, objections, related designation number, and court ruling).

Parties intending to use deposition or former trial testimony must meet and confer and jointly prepare and file a Joint Chart of Page and Line Designations.

Where an appropriate CACI special verdict form exists, the court expects the parties to use it for causes of action, affirmative defenses, or other findings.

For jury trials, parties must jointly file a proposed verdict form acceptable to all parties, or, if they cannot agree, each party must separately file a proposed verdict form.

Each designation and counter-designation in the Joint Chart must be highlighted, with each party using a different color highlighter.

Motions in limine must be noticed for hearing at the Final Status Conference.

More Judges in Los Angeles Superior Court

Michelle Lim
Judge
A. Ashley Tabaddor
Judge
Alan B. Honeycutt
Judge
Alexander C. D. Giza
Judge
Alison Mackenzie
Judge
Allison L. Westfahl Kong
Judge
Andrew E. Cooper
Judge
Andrew Esbenshade
Judge