New: a trial court in 1 of every 10 U.S. counties. Read the post
Court Rules
Judge

Judge Lewis Lubell

Individual Rules, Standing Orders & Policies

New York Supreme Court, Westchester County

Limits & Logistics

Document Limits

ApplicationCourt-wide
3 pgs
ResponseCourt-wide
3 pgs
LetterCourt-wide
1 pgs
BriefCourt-wide
40 pgs
Affidavit AffirmationCourt-wide
25 pgs
Pre Mediation MemorandumCourt-wide
5 pgs

Courtesy Copies

Attorney filings

Court-wide
  • 1 copy • Following Initial Notification

Courtesy copies

Court-wide
  • Civil, Pro Se:
  • Not required
  • Civil, Pro Se:Within 48 Hours

Note of Issue and Certificate of Readiness

Court-wide
  • Within Two Business Days

Stipulation of Discontinuance

Court-wide
  • 1 copy

Adjournments

  • An application to adjourn an appearance must be submitted on NYSCEF as a letter or stipulation unless an exception or exemption applies.
  • The adjournment letter or stipulation should state the appearance date, proposed adjourned date, number of prior adjournments, whether the adversary consents, and any reasons given for refusing consent.

Request must include

Original DateProposed New DatesNumber of Previous RequestsAdversary Position
48Hoursnotice
  • An adjournment request must be submitted at least 48 hours before the appearance unless good cause is shown.
Filters:

Document Format Requirements3 rules

FormattingMandatoryCivil cases

The verdict sheet is to be typed and in final form for presentation to the jury.

Applies to
  • Verdict sheet

Formatting

  • Typed
PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
FormattingMandatoryCivil cases

2) Contentions of the parties on one typed page, single spaced.

Line spacing
Single
Applies to
  • Contentions of parties

Formatting

  • One typed page
PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
FormattingImportantCivil cases

If it is feasible, such proposals shall also be submitted via e-mail to llubell@nycourts.gov such as is compatible with Microsoft Word or WordPerfect.

Formatting

  • Compatible with Microsoft Word or WordPerfect
PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials

Document Filing Requirements13 rules

Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

Unless otherwise inapplicable, an application for temporary injunctive relief must include either an affirmation detailing a good-faith notice effort or an affirmation stating that notice would significantly prejudice the applicant.

Court's wording

Unless otherwise inapplicable, any application for temporary injunctive relief shall comply with Uniform Rules for Trial Courts (22 NYCRR) § 202.7 (f) by including either: (i) an affirmation demonstrating that a good faith effort has been made to notify the party against whom the temporary restraining order is sought of the time, date and place that the application will be made in a manner sufficient to permit the party an opportunity to appear in response to the application, or (ii) an affirmation that there will be significant prejudice to the party seeking the restraining order by giving of notice.

PR lLubell · p. 2
|SectionII. Motions — C. Orders to Show Cause
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

If agreement cannot be reached, then each side shall present a separate proposed verdict sheet.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

Counsel shall jointly prepare a proposed verdict sheet.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

4) Pre-trial memoranda of law as to any known disputed legal issues that must be determined by the Court.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

5) A list of witnesses for each party.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

4) All previous judicial decisions, including appellate decisions, entered in the case.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

Requested charge deviations, additions, or charges requiring trial-related information must include the full request, included material, and supporting legal authority.

Court's wording

Where deviations, additions or charges which require the inclusion of information or material relative to the factual or legal issues adduced at trial are requested, the full text of such requests, including included material, must be submitted, together with any supporting legal authority.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

A complete list of requested charges is to be submitted via e-mail to llubell@nycourts.gov, notwithstanding the standard charges given by the Court.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsMandatoryCivil cases

1) Marked pleadings and an exhibit list.*

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsImportantCivil cases

Unless counsel seek a deviation from the pattern charge or additions to the pattern charge, only the PJI numbers and section title need be submitted.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsNoteCivil cases

Material to be used on cross-examination need not be listed on the exhibit list.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsNoteCivil cases

The final verdict sheet will be formalized during a charge conference to be held during the course of the trial after the conclusion of the case of the plaintiff(s).

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials
Filing RequirementsNoteCivil cases

Only those items received in evidence will be marked by the reporter.

PR lLubell · p. 3
|SectionIV. Trials

Filing & Service rules

Electronic Filing Rules

Every submission to the Court, including proposed orders, proposed judgments, and letters, must be electronically filed.

All submissions to the Court, including proposed orders, proposed judgments, and letters, must be e-filed.

Civil cases

Page 1 | I. E-Filing Rules and Protocol

All documents in E-Filing Cases must be filed through NYSCEF unless an exception or exemption applies.

All documents in E-Filing Cases must be filed through the New York State Courts E-Filing System (NYSCEF), unless subject to an exception or an exemption.

Civil cases

Page 1 | I. E-Filing Rules and Protocol

In e-filed cases, hard-copy submissions will be rejected unless accompanied by the completed Notice of Hard Copy Submission - E-Filed Case form.

This Part will reject any hard copy submissions in e-filed cases unless those submissions are accompanied by a completed “Notice of Hard Copy Submission - E-Filed Case” form, as required by Uniform Rules for Trial Courts (22 NYCRR) § 202.5-b (d) (1) (iv).3

Civil cases

Page 4 | V. General Matters

Service and Proof of Service Rules

All requests-to-charge submissions must be served on opposing counsel.

All submissions must be served on opposition counsel.

Civil cases

Page 3 | IV. Trials

Adjournment & Extension Requirements

An adjournment request must be submitted at least 48 hours before the appearance unless good cause is shown.

Such requests must be at least 48 hours prior to the date of the appearance, unless good cause shown.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — C. Applications to Adjourn an Appearance

An application to adjourn an appearance must be submitted on NYSCEF as a letter or stipulation unless an exception or exemption applies.

All requests for adjournments must be presented in the form of a letter or stipulation, submitted on NYSCEF, unless subject to an exception or an exemption.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — C. Applications to Adjourn an Appearance

The adjournment letter or stipulation should state the appearance date, proposed adjourned date, number of prior adjournments, whether the adversary consents, and any reasons given for refusing consent.

In either case, the letter or stipulation should state (1) the appearance date, (2) the proposed adjourned date, (3) the number of prior adjournments, and (4) whether the adversary consents, and, if not, the reasons given by the adversary for refusing to consent.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — C. Applications to Adjourn an Appearance

Chambers Communication Rules

Communications with Chambers must generally be submitted as letters on NYSCEF, subject to judicial direction and any exception or exemption.

Unless otherwise directed by Justice Lubell, communications with Chambers shall be by letter, submitted on NYSCEF, unless subject to an exception or an exemption.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — A. Letters

Unaddressed matters and emergencies requiring immediate attention should be raised by calling Chambers at 914-824-5392, leaving a message with the action name, index number, and call details if necessary.

For matters not addressed in these rules or in emergency situations requiring immediate attention, please call Chambers at 914-824-5392 and, if necessary, leave a message, noting the name and index number of the action and brief details as to the nature of the call.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — B. Telephone Calls

A letter requiring immediate attention should be emailed to Eva Nilsson-Smith in Chambers and also filed on NYSCEF.

If your submission requires immediate attention, please email the letter to Eva Nilsson-Smith in Chambers (etsmith@nycourts.gov) as well as filing the letter on NYSCEF.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — A. Letters

Questions about local procedures should be directed by phone to the Civil Department at 914-824-5300.

Specific questions relating to local procedures should be addressed to the Civil Department at 914-824-5300.

Civil cases

Page 1 | I. E-Filing Rules and Protocol

General e-filing questions may be directed to the E-Filing Resource Center by phone at 646-386-3033 or by email at efile@courts.state.ny.us.

General questions about e-filing should be addressed to the E-Filing Resource Center at 646-386-3033 or efile@courts.state.ny.us.

Civil cases

Page 1 | I. E-Filing Rules and Protocol

Scheduling and calendar matters should be handled by calling Part Clerk Joseph Tuohy at 914-824-5623 between 9 a.m. and 4:30 p.m.

For scheduling and calendar matters, please call the Part Clerk, Joseph Tuohy, at 914-824-5623 between 9 a.m. and 4:30 p.m.

Civil cases

Page 2 | III. Communications with Chambers — B. Telephone Calls

Court-wide rules

Applies court-wide

These 448 rules apply across New York Supreme Court, Westchester County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.

Filing Requirements

All 140
  • Applies to
    Preliminary conference order
    Must include
    proposed order

    At least 10 days before the Preliminary Conference, the parties’ attorneys must meet in person or by meaningful phone conference to review and complete the proposed order and address specified issues.

  • Applies to
    Statements of net worth

    The required Statements of Net Worth and attachments must be exchanged between counsel and/or self-represented parties.

  • Applies to
    Conference request
    Must include
    local rule certificate

    A written conference request must identify the issues and available participants and include a detailed 22 NYCRR §130-1.1(a) certification of the prior conference or good-faith resolution attempts.

E-Filing

All 60
  • Applies to
    Evidence

    In electronically filed actions, counsel are encouraged to file evidence through NYSCEF using applicable redactions and Bates-stamp or similar pagination for multipage evidence.

  • Applies to
    Proposed order

    The proposed Preliminary Conference Order must be submitted through NYSCEF at least two days before the scheduled conference.

  • Applies to
    Motion practice correspondence

    Motion practice may not be conducted by correspondence or email, and the court will not consider such communications.

Filing Timing

All 55
  • The proposed Preliminary Conference Order is due at least two days before the scheduled conference.

  • Counsel and self-represented parties must file the required Statements of Net Worth and attachments no later than 10 days before the Preliminary Conference.

  • A party opposing any part of an application must submit its opposition and basis within five days after receiving the application.

Communication

All 51
  • Contact
    Email

    The listed email address may be used only to request an initial foreclosure settlement conference for a voluntary case; the Court will respond by mail rather than email.

  • Contact
    Email

    If a motion or part of a motion settles before its return date or decision, the parties must immediately notify chambers or the court-attorney referee in writing by email.

  • When specified Family Court relief is sought while a matrimonial action remains pending and process has been served, the parties must promptly notify the assigned justice’s chambers or court-attorney referee.

About Judge Lewis Lubell
  • Law Clerk: Gardner Miller
  • Secretary: Eva Nilsson-Smith
  • Part Clerk: Joseph Tuohy
Common questions about Judge Lewis Lubell's rules

What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Lewis Lubell?

Judge Lewis Lubell's formatting rule includes single spacing and one typed page. The parties' contentions must be submitted on one typed, single-spaced page as soon as possible after trial begins.

View ruleSource: page 3, section IV. Trials

What must be included with verdict sheet filings before Judge Lewis Lubell?

Counsel must jointly prepare a proposed verdict sheet at the close of plaintiff's case.

View ruleSource: page 3, section IV. Trials

What must be included with marked pleadings filings before Judge Lewis Lubell?

Counsel must provide marked pleadings and an exhibit list as soon as possible after trial begins.

View ruleSource: page 3, section IV. Trials

How may parties contact Judge Lewis Lubell's chambers?

Communications with Chambers must generally be submitted as letters on NYSCEF, subject to judicial direction and any exception or exemption.

View ruleSource: page 2, section III. Communications with Chambers — A. Letters

How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Lewis Lubell?

An application to adjourn an appearance must be submitted on NYSCEF as a letter or stipulation unless an exception or exemption applies.

View ruleSource: page 2, section III. Communications with Chambers — C. Applications to Adjourn an Appearance

Is electronic filing required before Judge Lewis Lubell?

Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. All documents in E-Filing Cases must be filed through NYSCEF unless an exception or exemption applies.

View ruleSource: page 1, section I. E-Filing Rules and Protocol

What rule applies to service for requests to charge before Judge Lewis Lubell?

Details: method: service by email, recipient: the opposing party. All requests-to-charge submissions must be served on opposing counsel.

View ruleSource: page 3, section IV. Trials
Complete rules summary for Judge Lewis Lubell

Counsel must jointly prepare a proposed verdict sheet at the close of plaintiff's case.

Counsel must provide marked pleadings and an exhibit list as soon as possible after trial begins.

All documents in E-Filing Cases must be filed through NYSCEF unless an exception or exemption applies.

Every submission to the Court, including proposed orders, proposed judgments, and letters, must be electronically filed.

General e-filing questions may be directed to the E-Filing Resource Center by phone at 646-386-3033 or by email at efile@courts.state.ny.us.

Questions about local procedures should be directed by phone to the Civil Department at 914-824-5300.

Unless otherwise inapplicable, an application for temporary injunctive relief must include either an affirmation detailing a good-faith notice effort or an affirmation stating that notice would significantly prejudice the applicant.

Communications with Chambers must generally be submitted as letters on NYSCEF, subject to judicial direction and any exception or exemption.

A letter requiring immediate attention should be emailed to Eva Nilsson-Smith in Chambers and also filed on NYSCEF.

Scheduling and calendar matters should be handled by calling Part Clerk Joseph Tuohy at 914-824-5623 between 9 a.m. and 4:30 p.m.

Unaddressed matters and emergencies requiring immediate attention should be raised by calling Chambers at 914-824-5392, leaving a message with the action name, index number, and call details if necessary.

An application to adjourn an appearance must be submitted on NYSCEF as a letter or stipulation unless an exception or exemption applies.

The adjournment letter or stipulation should state the appearance date, proposed adjourned date, number of prior adjournments, whether the adversary consents, and any reasons given for refusing consent.

An adjournment request must be submitted at least 48 hours before the appearance unless good cause is shown.

Material intended for use on cross-examination does not have to be included on the exhibit list.

Counsel must provide all previous judicial decisions entered in the case, including appellate decisions, as soon as possible after trial begins.

All requests-to-charge submissions must be served on opposing counsel.

The parties' contentions must be submitted on one typed, single-spaced page as soon as possible after trial begins.

Counsel must provide pretrial memoranda addressing known disputed legal issues that the Court must determine.

Submit a complete list of requested charges by e-mail to llubell@nycourts.gov, even if the Court has provided standard charges.

For standard pattern charges, only the PJI numbers and section titles must be submitted unless a deviation or addition is requested.

Requested charge deviations, additions, or charges requiring trial-related information must include the full request, included material, and supporting legal authority.

The proposed verdict sheet must be typed and submitted in final form for presentation to the jury.

If the parties cannot agree on a proposed verdict sheet, each side must present a separate proposed verdict sheet.

When feasible, parties must also submit the proposals by e-mail in a format compatible with Microsoft Word or WordPerfect.

The final verdict sheet will be formalized at a charge conference during the trial after the conclusion of plaintiff's case.

In e-filed cases, hard-copy submissions will be rejected unless accompanied by the completed Notice of Hard Copy Submission - E-Filed Case form.

The reporter will mark only the items received in evidence.

Counsel must provide a list of witnesses for each party as soon as possible after trial begins.

More Judges in New York Supreme Court, Westchester County

Alexandra D. Murphy
Judge
Amy S. Puerto
Judge
Anne E. Minihan
Judge
Charles D. Wood
Judge
Christie L. D'Alessio
Judge
David F. Everett
Judge
David J. Squirrell
Judge
David S. Zuckerman
Judge