New: a trial court in 1 of every 10 U.S. counties. Read the post
Court Rules
Judge

Judge Mary Ann Brigantti

Individual Rules, Standing Orders & Policies

New York Supreme Court, Bronx County

Limits & Logistics

Courtesy Copies

Courtesy copies

  • Not required

Motion

Court-wide

Opposition, Reply

Court-wide

Proposed Order, Supporting Documents

Court-wide

Adjournments

  • Conference adjournments will not be granted unless the requesting party shows good cause.
  • Parties must strictly comply with discovery deadlines in the CSO, and extensions will be granted only for good cause or by a stipulation signed by all appearing parties.
  • Parties may not stipulate to adjourn an in-person conference or argument, and failure to appear may result in a default.
  • +11 more

Request must include

Reason for Request
48Hoursnotice
  • An adjournment request for a remote conference must be written, transmitted to the court and all parties at least 48 hours beforehand, and state whether the other parties consent.

Communication

Email
enewcomb@nycourts.gov
Email
cchambless@nycourts.gov
Email

Clerk

bxsupciv-ia25@nycourts.gov
Phone

Chambers

Emergencies
Filters:

Document Format Requirements10 rules

FormattingMandatory

Electronically submitted memoranda of law, affidavits, and affirmations exceeding 4,500 words must include bookmarks listing the contents and facilitating navigation.

Applies to
  • More than 4,500 words

Court's wording

Each electronically submitted memorandum of law, affidavit and affirmation, exceeding 4500 words, shall include bookmarks providing a listing of the document’s contents and facilitating easy navigation by the reader within the document (see Subdivision (a) of section 202.5of the Uniform Civil Rules for the Supreme Court and the County Court).

IA-25 · p. 3
|SectionForm of Papers
FormattingMandatory

Copies must be legible.

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
FormattingImportant

if typewritten, shall have at least double space between each line, except for quotations and the names and addresses of attorneys appearing in the action

Line spacing
At least double

Exception

Quotations and the names and addresses of attorneys appearing in the action

IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
FormattingImportant

every paper filed in court, other than an exhibit or printed form, shall contain writing on one side only, except that papers that are fastened on the side may contain writing on both sides

IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
FormattingImportant

and shall contain print no smaller than 12-point, or 8 ½ x 11-inch paper, bearing margins no smaller than one inch.

Font size
At least 12 points
Margins
At least 1 inch
Paper size
Letter
IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
FormattingImportant

The print size of footnotes shall be no smaller than 10 point.

Font size
At least 10 points
IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
FormattingImportant

and shall have at least one-inch margins.

Margins
At least 1 inch
IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
FormattingImportant

When submitting a request to “so-order”, to the extent feasible, ensure the signature lines are not on a separate page from the content of the proposed order or stipulation. If not feasible, include at the end of the content of the stipulation or proposed order “[INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]”. On the signature page, include a header in the top right-hand corner of the page containing the following information: Case Caption Index No. [#] Mot. Seq. [#] Page [#] of

IA-25 · p. 6
|SectionRequests to “So-Order”
FormattingImportant

Counsel should use tabs on hard or working copies when submitting papers containing exhibits.

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
FormattingImportant

C. Parties must still bring original copies of exhibits to the inquest.

IA-25 · p. 14
|SectionInquests

Document Filing Requirements36 rules

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Where an action has already been initiated by the filing of a Summons and Complaint, an ICO should be sought through an ex parte application filed to NYSCEF using the label “Infant Compromise Order (Proposed).”

Document
Ex parte infant compromise order application

Should include

  • Infant Compromise Order (Proposed)
IA-25 · p. 4
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

If an ICO application does not strictly comply with the requirements set forth in these provisions, approval of the ICO will be delayed until full compliance is reached through additional or amended submissions.

IA-25 · p. 4
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The physician affirmation, medical records, or hospital report must contain specified medical-history, examination, diagnosis, prognosis, recovery, and treatment information.

Court's wording

The affirmation, records, or report must include: (i) history obtained; (ii) infant’s complaints of pain and/or limitations (past, recent and present); (iii) treatment rendered; (iv) details of the examination recently rendered upon which current opinion and conclusion is based; (v) diagnosis; (vi) prognosis, especially if the infant does have any current, or in the recent past has had, any limitations or complaints of pain; and (vii) whether the infant has fully recovered from the injuries or requires additional treatment; and (viii) any additional opinions, conclusions, and treatment recommendations.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Counsel and unrepresented litigants must use the Infant Compromise Order checklist before submitting a proposed ICO.

Court's wording

To avoid delay and ensure that all required documentation is submitted, counsel or unrepresented litigants shall utilize an Infant Compromise Order checklist, uploaded to the New York Courts website and found in Room 217, before submitting a proposed ICO. Proposed ICOs without the required documentation will delay processing and may eventually be rejected.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

If the infant is 14 or more years old, an affidavit from the infant attesting to his or her understanding of the settlement and consenting to is required.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The proposed ICO shall provide (i) the name and address of a savings bank (as opposed to a commercial bank) in Bronx County in which the settlement funds will be deposited; (ii) whether the attorney is waiving expenses/disbursements or the Attorney’s fee is inclusive of the expenses/disbursements.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The Court requires an affirmation from a physician or medical records indicating infant has been examined within the six months prior to the submission of the proposed order.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

To the extent not already mandated by CPLR 1208(a) and Uniform Rule 202.67(b), the guardian affidavit must also: (1) state the guardian's relationship to the infant; (2) specifically set out the medical treatment that the infant received, the names of the physicians rendering the treatment, the charges incurred for the treatment, and whether any balance remains due on those charges; and (3) waive the guardian's claim, if any, for loss of the infant’s services.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The attorney affirmation must provide specified information about non-waived expenses, insurance, liens, and prior settlements, except where CPLR 1208 or section 202.67 already requires it.

Court's wording

To the extent not mandated by CPLR 1208 and section 202.67, the affirmation shall also provide (i) an itemized list of the expenses/disbursements that are not waived or inclusive of the attorney’s fee; (ii) the amount of available insurance, including excess insurance; (iii) whether there are any applicable liens and their amount; and (iv) whether the guardian or others involved in the accident received settlements and, if so, the others’ injuries and the amount paid to each.

IA-25 · p. 5
|SectionInfant Compromise Orders
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The parties are directed to jointly complete the CSO, and Plaintiff is directed to upload the same to NYSCEF and email a copy of it to the Court’s Part email at bxsupciv- IA25@nycourts.gov, no later than one day prior to the date of the PC.

IA-25 · p. 6
|SectionDiscovery — Preliminary Conferences
Filing RequirementsMandatory

When a preliminary conference is needed, the parties must confer and jointly complete and submit the Part’s standard PC and CSO.

Court's wording

If you require a preliminary conference, the parties MUST confer with one another, and jointly complete and submit to the Court the Preliminary Conference (‘PC”) and Case Scheduling Order (“CSO”), which can be found on the Bronx County Supreme Court’s part rules webpage. Please note that the parties must use this Part’s standard PC and CSO.

IA-25 · p. 6
|SectionDiscovery — Preliminary Conferences
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The stipulation must certify that all discovery is complete and provide for the filing of the Note of Issue.

IA-25 · p. 7
|Section2. Status/Compliance Conference
Filing RequirementsMandatory

If a document to be annexed to an affidavit or affirmation is voluminous and only discrete portions are relevant to the motion, counsel shall attach excerpts and submit the full exhibit separately.

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Counsel must include with motion papers all pleadings and other documents required by the CPLR or necessary for an informed decision, regardless of the filing format.

Court's wording

Regardless of whether the papers are filed electronically or in hard copy or as working copies, counsel must submit as part of the motion papers, copies of all pleadings and other documents as required by the CPLR and as necessary for an informed decision on the motion (especially on motions pursuant to CPLR 3211 and 3212).

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Documents in a foreign language shall be translated as required by CPLR 2101(b).

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Whenever reliance is placed upon a decision or other authority not readily available to the court, a copy of the case or of pertinent portions of the authority shall be submitted with the motion papers.

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The movant shall specify in the notice of motion, order to show cause, and in a concluding section of a memorandum of law, the exact relief sought.

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Form of Motion Papers
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Every movant or opponent material-fact paragraph, including a controverting paragraph, must be followed by a citation to supporting or opposing evidence.

Court's wording

Each statement of material fact by the movant or opponent pursuant to subdivision (i)or (ii), including each statement controverting any statement of material fact, must be followed by citation to evidence submitted in support of or in opposition to the motion.

IA-25 · p. 9
|Section4. Summary Judgment Motions
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Except for a CPLR 3213 motion, the moving party must annex a separate, concise, numbered statement of undisputed material facts to the notice of motion.

Court's wording

Upon any motion for summary judgment, other than a motion made pursuant to CPLR 3213, there shall be annexed to the notice of motion a separate, short and concise statement, in numbered paragraphs, of the material facts as to which the moving party contends there is no genuine issue to be tried.

IA-25 · p. 9
|Section4. Summary Judgment Motions
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Opposition papers must respond in corresponding numbered paragraphs to every material-fact paragraph and, if necessary, state additional disputed material facts in separate concise paragraphs.

Document
Opposition

Must include

  • Statement of facts

Court's wording

In such a case, the papers opposing a motion for summary judgment shall include a correspondingly numbered paragraph responding to each numbered paragraph in the statement of the moving party and, if necessary, additional paragraphs containing a separate short and concise statement of the material facts as to which it is contended that there exists a genuine issue to be tried.

IA-25 · p. 9
|Section4. Summary Judgment Motions
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Sur-replies and merit-addressing correspondence are prohibited without advance permission, except for a citation-only letter identifying a relevant post-submission decision; violating materials will be ignored and may not be answered in kind.

Court's wording

Absent express permission in advance, sur-reply papers, including correspondence, addressing the merits of a motion are not permitted, except that counsel may inform the court by letter of the citation of any post-submission court decision that is relevant to the pending issues, but there shall be no additional argument. Materials submitted in violation hereof will not be read or considered. Opposing counsel who receives a copy of materials submitted in violation of this Rule shall not respond in kind.

IA-25 · p. 9
|Section3. Sur-Reply and Post-Submission Papers
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Absent advance permission of the court, reply papers shall not be submitted on orders to show cause.

IA-25 · p. 10
|Section6. Orders to Show Cause
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Any party seeking immediate injunctive relief within an OSC must appear with the affected adversary (or with proof the adversary has been notified, but declined to appear pursuant to 202.7[f]) when the application is presented for signature.

IA-25 · p. 10
|Section6. Orders to Show Cause
Filing RequirementsMandatory

An order to show cause may be used only for genuine urgency, a required stay, or a statutory mandate to proceed.

Court's wording

Motions shall be brought on by order to show cause only when there is genuine urgency (e.g., applications for provisional relief), a stay is required, or a statute mandate so proceeding (see Section 202.8-e).

IA-25 · p. 10
|Section6. Orders to Show Cause
Filing RequirementsMandatory

A party that does not use any AI to draft papers submitted to the Court shall submit an affirmation certifying that no AI was used to prepare them.

Court's wording

A Party does not use AI. If a party does not use any AI in the drafting of the papers submitted to the Court, the party shall submit an affirmation certifying that that no AI was used in the preparation of the party’s papers submitted to the Court.

IA-25 · p. 11
|Section7. Affirmation regarding the use of Artificial Intelligence (“AI”)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

A party using AI to draft a paper that cites law must submit a separate affirmation describing the AI’s purpose, legal issues, and service and certifying that all AI-generated legal authorities were cite-checked and support the propositions for which they are used.

Document
Paper citing law

Must include

  • AI disclosure

Court's wording

A Party uses AI. If any AI is used in the drafting of papers submitted to this Court, the Party must submit a separate affirmation detailing the following: (1) for what purpose the AI was being used;(2) for which legal issue(s) AI is used; (3) which AI service was used; and (4) that any and all case law which was generated by AI and used in the submission has been cite-checked and proofed to ensure the case, statute, rule, treatise, or other legal source exists and that such law or source supports what the party argues that it supports.

IA-25 · p. 11
|Section7. Affirmation regarding the use of Artificial Intelligence (“AI”)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

A. Submissions in support of an inquest shall include, when applicable: ... vi. Proposed findings of fact citing to the evidence Plaintiff seeks to admit and a proposed order.

Document
Inquest supporting submission

Must include

  • Proposed order
IA-25 · p. 14
|SectionInquests
Filing RequirementsMandatory

At the commencement of the trial all counsel shall submit suggested jury charges and a suggested verdict questionnaire.

IA-25 · p. 14
|SectionJury Charge & Verdict Sheet
Filing RequirementsImportant

Thereafter such number shall appear on the outside cover and first page to the right of the caption of every paper tendered for filing in the action.

Document
Paper
Placement
First page
IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
Filing RequirementsImportant

Each such cover and first page also shall contain an indication of the county of venue,a brief description of the nature of the paper and, where the case has been assigned to an individual judge, shall contain the name of the assigned judge to the right of the caption.

IA-25 · p. 2
|SectionI. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers
Filing RequirementsImportant

When appropriate, proposed orders should be submitted with motions, e.g., motions to be relieved, pro hac vice admissions, open commissions, etc.

Document
Motion

Should include

  • Proposed order
IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Proposed orders
Filing RequirementsImportant

No proposed order should be submitted with motion papers on a dispositive motion.

IA-25 · p. 8
|SectionIII. Motions — 1. Generally — Proposed orders
Filing RequirementsImportant

A movant's supported material-fact paragraph is deemed admitted unless specifically controverted by a correspondingly numbered paragraph in the opposition statement.

Court's wording

Each numbered paragraph in the statement of material facts required to be served by the moving party will be deemed to be admitted, to the extent such statement is supported by the cited evidence, unless specifically controverted by a correspondingly numbered paragraph in the statement required to be served by the opposing party.

IA-25 · p. 9
|Section4. Summary Judgment Motions
Filing RequirementsImportant

Any party may request an oral argument on a non-dispositive motion by letter accompanying the motion papers.

IA-25 · p. 10
|Section5. Oral Argument
Filing RequirementsImportant

Dispositive motions will be scheduled for oral argument by the Court upon written request.

IA-25 · p. 10
|Section5. Oral Argument
Filing RequirementsImportant

If any changes to the PJI are suggested, then the entire proposed charge should be set forth and the changes should be highlighted or otherwise called to the Court’ s attention.

IA-25 · p. 14
|SectionJury Charge & Verdict Sheet

Filing & Service rules

Electronic Filing Rules

A hard copy must not be submitted for papers filed in an electronically filed case.

Do not submit a hard copy of papers filed in an electronically filed case.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers

Fax submissions must comply with section 202.5 and may not be sent to the court without the Part's advance approval.

Papers and correspondence filed by fax shall comply with the requirements of section 202.5 except that papers shall not be submitted to the court by fax without advance approval of this Part.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Electronic Submission of Papers

A settlement-conference request supported by a stipulation signed by all parties must be emailed to the listed addresses and filed by letter on NYSCEF.

At any time during the pendency of an action, as long as all parties sign a Stipulation requesting a settlement conference, the Court will be available to facilitate settlement conferences. Any such request must be emailed to enewcomb@nycourts.gov, cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov and filed by letter on NYSCEF.

Page 4 | Settlement Conferences

A stipulation or proposed order submitted for so-ordering must be emailed to the three listed addresses and filed on NYSCEF.

The stipulation/proposed order must emailed to enewcomb@nycourts.gov, cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov. and filed on NYSCEF.

Page 6 | Requests to “So-Order”

The parties must fully execute, e-file, and e-mail a stipulation to the listed addresses no later than the scheduled Status/Compliance Conference date when all outstanding discovery issues have been resolved.

If the parties agree on all issues relating to outstanding discovery prior to the compliance conference date, the parties shall e-file and e-mail a fully executed stipulation to enewcomb@nycourts.gov, cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov on or before the scheduled Status/Compliance conference date.

Page 7 | 2. Status/Compliance Conference

An adjournment request made before the scheduled date must be written, e-filed, and e-mailed to the three listed Chambers addresses for approval.

All requests for adjournments prior to the scheduled date must be made in writing, e-filed, and e-mailed to Chambers at enewcomb@nycourts.gov, cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov for approval.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 2. Motion Adjournments

An in-person appearance is required if the PC and CSO are not electronically filed by one day before the scheduled preliminary conference.

No appearances are necessary if a PC and CSO is electronically filed no later than one day prior to the scheduled PC otherwise an IN-PERSON APPEARANCE is required to submit a completed CSO on a scheduled PC.

Page 6 | Discovery — Preliminary Conferences

Fax or electronic submissions ordinarily should not be followed by a hard copy unless the court requests one.

Papers and correspondence sent by fax or submitted electronically should not be followed by hard copy unless requested.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Electronic Submission of Papers

For cases not pending in the court's Filing by Electronic Means System, the court may permit email communication.

In cases not pending in the court’s Filing by Electronic Means System, the court may permit counsel to communicate with the court and each other by e-mail.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Electronic Submission of Papers

Filing Timing and Cure Windows

A CPLR 3212(a) summary-judgment motion ordinarily must be filed no later than 60 days after the note of issue is filed, unless the court grants leave for good cause.

PURSUANT TO CPLR 3212(a), A MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT SHALL BE MADE NO LATER THAN SIXTY (60) DAYS AFTER THE FILING OF THE NOTE OF ISSUE, EXCEPT WITH LEAVE OF COURT ON GOOD CAUSE SHOWN.

Page 9 | 4. Summary Judgment Motions

Unless the signed order to show cause states otherwise, opposition papers are due two days before the return date.

Unless otherwise stated on the signed OSC, opposition papers are due two days in advance of the return date.

Page 10 | 6. Orders to Show Cause

Evidentiary packages must be submitted to the court at least 24 hours before jury selection.

Evidentiary packages must be presented to the Court at least 24 hours before jury selection.

Page 14 | Summary Jury Trials

Submissions opposing an inquest are due at least one business day before the inquest.

Submissions in opposition are due at least one business day prior to the inquest.

Page 15 | G.

Submissions supporting an inquest are due at least three business days before the inquest.

Submissions in support of the inquest are due at least three (3) business days prior to the inquest.

Page 15 | G.

Written notice of the specified settlement or case-status events must be provided to the court part within two weeks or earlier.

Such notification shall be made to this Part in writing within two weeks of said event or earlier.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Settlements and Discontinuances

A party may request a virtual oral argument by filing a letter or stipulation at least one week before the argument and emailing a copy to the three listed court addresses.

Parties may request that oral arguments are held virtually by filing a letter or stipulation with the court at least one week in advance of the scheduled argument date and emailing a copy of such letter to enewcomb@nycourts.gov, cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov.

Page 10 | 5. Oral Argument

When practicable, the Court will provide at least 14 days' notice of the selected date for oral argument.

Notice of the date selected by the court shall be given, if practicable, at least 14 days before the scheduled oral argument.

Page 10 | 5. Oral Argument

Service and Proof of Service Rules

Each attorney notified of a scheduled appearance must notify all other parties by email of the assigned date and time.

Second, each attorney who receives notification of an appearance on a specific date and time is responsible for notifying all other parties by e-mail that the matter is scheduled to be heard on that assigned date and time (Section 202.23[c]).

Page 3 | Remote appearances via Microsoft Teams

Proof of service for an order to show cause must be filed with the Clerk and emailed to all three listed court addresses by 9:00 AM one day before the return date; noncompliance results in denial.

Proof of service must be filed with the Clerk, and e-mailed to the Court (enewcomb@nycourts.gov; cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov). by 9:00 AM one day prior to the return date. Non-compliance shall result in denial of the Order to Show Cause.

Page 10 | 6. Orders to Show Cause

Inquest submissions must include proof of service for all papers and exhibits submitted to the court, together with notice of the inquest date, time, and location as required by the CPLR.

v. Proof of service of all papers and exhibits submitted to the court, along with notice of the inquest date, time, and location on all opposing parties to the extent required by the CPLR;

Page 14 | Inquests

Every paper filed in court must include appropriate proof of service on all parties when service is required.

In addition to complying with the provisions of CPLR 2101, every paper filed in court shall have annexed thereto appropriate proof of service on all parties where required

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers

The party filing the first paper must promptly communicate the county clerk's index number in writing to all other parties.

The party causing the first paper to be filed shall communicate in writing the county clerk’s index number forthwith to all other parties to the action.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers

Filing Fees and Waivers

The party filing the first paper must pay the proper fee, obtain an index number from the county clerk, and affix it to the paper.

The party filing the first paper in an action, upon payment of the proper fee, shall obtain from the county clerk an index number, which shall be affixed to the paper.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers

Courtesy Copy Requirements

In the court's discretion, counsel maybe requested to submit memoranda of law by e-mail or by other electronic means, such as by a computer flash drive, along with an original and courtesy copy.

In the court's discretion, counsel maybe requested to submit memoranda of law by e-mail or by other electronic means, such as by a computer flash drive, along with an original and courtesy copy.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Electronic Submission of Papers

Chambers does not require working copies of motion papers that are filed electronically.

Chambers does not require working copies of e-filed motion papers (see Administrative Order AO/121/20).

Page 8 | III. Motions — 1. Generally

Sealing & Redaction Procedures

The infant’s full name and full date of birth, rather than initials and year alone, must be redacted in every electronically filed document.

The infant’s full name (other than initials) and date of birth (other than year) shall be redacted in all e-filed documents.

Page 4 | Infant Compromise Orders

Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

Email exchange alone is insufficient unless the affirmation documents the communication history or the other party’s refusal to communicate by telephone, virtually, or in person.

Emails alone do not satisfy the requirements of 22 NYCRR 202.20-f, unless the affirmation includes a history or an indication that the non-complying party has refused to communicate over the phone, virtually, or in-person.

Page 7 | 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

A conference ordinarily requires a telephone, virtual, or in-person meeting with the party from whom discovery is requested.

A party has not fulfilled its obligation to confer pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.20-f unless they have spoken over the phone or have met virtually or in-person with the party from whom the moving party is requesting discovery.

Page 7 | 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

A party may file a discovery motion only after conferring in good faith with the party from whom discovery is sought.

A Discovery Motion shall only be made after the parties have conferred in good faith.

Page 7 | 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

Motions are ordinarily decided on submission unless the Court specifically schedules oral argument or a conference.

All motions will be decided “on submission” unless specifically scheduled for oral argument/conference before the Court.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 1. Generally

Adjournment & Extension Requirements

An adjournment request for a remote conference must be written, transmitted to the court and all parties at least 48 hours beforehand, and state whether the other parties consent.

Finally, requests for adjournments shall be transmitted in writing to the Court and to all parties no later than 48 hours before the conference and shall set forth whether the other parties consent to the adjournment (Section 202.23[d]).

Page 3 | Remote appearances via Microsoft Teams

Conference adjournments will not be granted unless the requesting party shows good cause.

No adjournments will be granted for conferences unless good cause is shown.

Page 4 | Pre-Trial Conference

Parties must strictly comply with discovery deadlines in the CSO, and extensions will be granted only for good cause or by a stipulation signed by all appearing parties.

Parties shall strictly comply with discovery obligations by the dates set forth in the CSO (22 NYCRR §202.20-e). Extensions of deadlines set forth in the CSO will only be granted upon a showing of good cause or on stipulation signed by all appearing parties.

Page 6 | Discovery — Preliminary Conferences

Parties may not stipulate to adjourn an in-person conference or argument, and failure to appear may result in a default.

Parties may NOT stipulate to adjourn any in-person conference/argument, and failure to appear will result in default (22 NYCRR § 202.27).

Page 7 | 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

A default resulting from failure to appear may be vacated only by motion.

Defaults will only be vacated on motion.

Page 7 | 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

The Court will not consider correspondence requesting vacatur of a default for failure to appear.

The Court will not entertain any correspondence related to vacating a default for failure to appear.

Page 7 | 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

A party seeking an adjournment must ensure that it is granted before the scheduled date to avoid a default determination.

All parties requesting an adjournment must ensure that such request has been granted prior to the scheduled date in order to avoid a default determination being entered.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 2. Motion Adjournments

The parties are responsible for determining whether the Court approved the adjournment stipulation.

It is the burden of the parties to inquire as to whether the stipulation was approved by the Court.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 2. Motion Adjournments

Before requesting any adjournment from the Court, the parties must use best efforts to obtain their adversaries’ consent.

The parties shall use their best efforts to obtain consent from their adversaries prior to requesting an adjournment of any sort from the Court.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 2. Motion Adjournments

Absent a contrary court order, a motion may not be adjourned by consent more than three times.

Unless the court orders otherwise, no motion may be adjourned on consent more than three times or for accumulative total of more than 60 days.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 2. Motion Adjournments

The Court will not entertain oral requests for an adjournment.

Oral applications will not be entertained—no exceptions.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 2. Motion Adjournments

An adjournment request requiring an explanation will be denied if the requesting party does not provide it.

If the requesting party does not provide an explanation under these circumstances, the adjournment request will be denied.

Page 9 | 3. Sur-Reply and Post-Submission Papers

Every one-sided adjournment request must include an explanation regardless of the requested duration.

One-sided requests for adjournments must always include an explanation for the request.

Page 9 | 3. Sur-Reply and Post-Submission Papers

A stipulated request to adjourn a motion that has already been adjourned more than three times must include an explanation.

Any Stipulation requesting an adjournment of a motion that has already been adjourned more than three times must include an explanation for the request.

Page 9 | 3. Sur-Reply and Post-Submission Papers

A stipulated motion adjournment longer than 60 days after the original return date must include an explanation, and an unexplained request will be denied.

Any Stipulations requesting a more than sixty (60) day adjournment after the original return date on a motion must include an explanation for the request.

Page 9 | 3. Sur-Reply and Post-Submission Papers

Chambers Communication Rules

The court does not accept ex parte communications.

Under no circumstances will ex parte communications be accepted.

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Communications with Chambers

Counsel must immediately notify the assigned judge or court part and Chambers by submitting the stipulation or a letter to the part clerk and sending notice by email when an action is settled, discontinued, or otherwise disposed of.

If an action is settled, discontinued, or otherwise disposed of, counsel shall immediately inform the assigned judge or court part by submission of a copy of the stipulation or a letter directed to the clerk of the part along with notice to the chambers of this Part via email

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Settlements and Discontinuances

Counsel, including self-represented litigants, must promptly notify the court of settlement, discontinuance, disposition, mootness, death, or bankruptcy.

Counsel, including self-represented litigants, are under a continuing obligation to notify the court as promptly as possible in the event that an action is settled, discontinued or otherwise disposed of, if a case or motion has become wholly or partially moot, or if a party has died or filed a petition in bankruptcy.

Page 2 | I. GENERAL RULES — Settlements and Discontinuances

Parties must contact the Court immediately when developments may affect the resolution of a pending motion.

Please contact the Court immediately if there has been any developments in a case that would affect the resolution of a pending motion (i.e., settlement, stipulation to adjourn, withdrawal, etc.).

Page 8 | III. Motions — 1. Generally

Every email sent to the Court must include all other parties in the case.

Parties MUST copy all other parties in the case on any e-mail sent to the Court.

Page 8 | III. Motions — 1. Generally

A party leaving the courtroom must provide current contact information, including a cell phone number, on the outside calendar or with the clerk.

If a party leaves the Courtroom, for however long, the party must write their contact information, including cell phone number, on the paper calendar outside the Courtroom or leave such information with the clerk.

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Appearance by Counsel with Knowledge and Authority

Attorneys and pro se parties must check in with the Part Clerk when entering the courtroom.

Attorneys or Pro se parties must check in with the Part Clerk when they enter the Courtroom.

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Appearance by Counsel with Knowledge and Authority

Telephone calls to Chambers are permitted only for emergencies requiring immediate attention.

Telephone calls to Chambers are permitted only in emergency situations requiring immediate attention.

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Communications with Chambers

An unanswered Chambers call requires a voicemail containing the person's identifying and contact information, index number, and a brief explanation of the issue.

If a call is not answered, leave a voicemail message with your name, telephone number, email address, index number, and a short explanation of the issue, and chambers will return your call as soon as possible.

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Communications with Chambers

Letters and emails sent to the court must copy all parties and must be e-filed when applicable.

Any letters or emails sent to the Court shall copy all parties to the case, and if applicable, be e-filed.

Page 1 | I. GENERAL RULES — Communications with Chambers

Decisions and orders are available online through NYSCEF or the Bronx County Clerk, and telephone inquiries about whether a decision has issued are prohibited.

All decisions and orders (including discovery orders and stipulations) are scanned and available on the Internet (NYSCEF or Bronx County Clerk). Do not call to ask whether a decision has been issued.

Page 3 | Availability of Decisions and Orders

An interpreter request for an infant compromise order proceeding should be emailed to the three listed addresses at least seven days before the proceeding.

A request for an interpreter for an ICO proceeding should be made via email to enewcomb@nycourts.gov, cchambless@nycourts.gov and bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov at least seven (7) days before the proceeding.

Page 6 | Infant Compromise Orders

If a nonmoving party appears or objects to injunctive relief by the time the order to show cause is filed, the parties must contact Chambers to arrange a Microsoft Teams appearance.

The parties shall contact chambers to arrange for their appearance via Microsoft Teams if the non-moving parties appear or file an objection to the injunctive relief when or prior to when the OSC is filed.

Page 10 | 6. Orders to Show Cause

After all inquest submissions have been filed, email the part clerk at bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov.

F. You are directed to email the part clerk at bxsupciv-IA25@nycourts.gov once all your submissions have been filed.

Page 14 | Inquests

The Part Clerk may provide information about scheduling conferences and motion arguments.

The Part Clerk can also provide information about scheduling of cases (conferences and argument of motions) in the Part (ext. 1252).

Page 3 | Information on Cases

Case and calendar status inquiries should initially be directed to the IAS Motion Support Office in Room 217.

All inquiries as to case or calendar status should, in the first instance, be made to the appropriate clerk’s office: IAS Motion Support Office, Room 217 (ext. 1310).

Page 3 | Information on Cases

Court-wide rules

Applies court-wide

These 98 rules apply across New York Supreme Court, Bronx County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.

Filing Requirements

All 29
  • Applies to
    Agreement to mediate

    In matrimonial presumptive mediation cases, all parties or their attorneys must complete the agreement to mediate, upload it to NYSCEF, and email a copy to the Matrimonial ADR Coordinator.

  • Applies to
    Agreement to mediate

    In non-matrimonial presumptive mediation cases, all parties or their attorneys must complete the agreement to mediate, upload it to NYSCEF, and email a copy to the ADR Department.

  • Applies to
    Working copy

    Each covered document must first be filed through NYSCEF, after which its working copy delivered to the Part must have a firmly affixed, outward-facing copy of the related NYSCEF Notice on the back page; the Part will not accept a working copy without that notice.

E-Filing

All 18
  • Applies to
    Agreement to mediate

    The completed agreement to mediate must be submitted through NYSCEF, with an additional copy emailed to BXSUPADR@nycourts.gov.

  • Applies to
    Agreement to mediate

    The completed matrimonial agreement to mediate must be submitted through NYSCEF, with an additional copy emailed to BXSUPADRMAT@NYCourts.gov.

  • A motion on notice or notice of petition in a New York Supreme Court e-filed case must be filed through NYSCEF.

Filing Timing

All 18
  • Deadline
    3 business days

    The supporting papers and proof of hard-copy service must be e-filed within three business days after service.

  • After filing through NYSCEF and paying the motion fee, the Motion Support Office automatically calendars the matter, and the filer need not take further action.

  • Proof of Service of the Orders to Show Cause, as well as any interposed Counterclaims or Answers, shall be e-filed with NYSCEF or filed with the Court in cases that are not e- filed, and may also be emailed to bxsup-electionmatters@nycourts.gov on or before April 22, 2024, by 9:30 a.m.

Adjournments

All 10
  • A compliant motion adjournment may be obtained by filing a stipulation of all parties through NYSCEF using the designated Stipulation to Adjourn Motion filing.

  • A non-stipulated adjournment or notice request is sent to Chambers for judicial decision, and the requesting attorney must notify the adversary of the result.

  • An adjournment of the hearing's commencement requires compelling reasons and approval from both the Referee and the referring Justice.

About Judge Mary Ann Brigantti
  • Part: Part IA-25
  • Part Clerk: (718) 618-1252
Common questions about Judge Mary Ann Brigantti's rules

Are courtesy copies required for Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

In the court's discretion, counsel maybe requested to submit memoranda of law by e-mail or by other electronic means, such as by a computer flash drive, along with an original and courtesy copy.

View ruleSource: page 2, section I. GENERAL RULES — Electronic Submission of Papers

Does Judge Mary Ann Brigantti require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?

Email exchange alone is insufficient unless the affirmation documents the communication history or the other party’s refusal to communicate by telephone, virtually, or in person.

View ruleSource: page 7, section 3. Discovery Motions & Conferences

What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

Judge Mary Ann Brigantti's formatting rule includes margins top 1 inches, bottom 1 inches, left 1 inches, right 1 inches. Every filed paper must have margins of at least one inch.

View ruleSource: page 2, section I. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers

What must be included with infant compromise order application filings before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

Approval of an infant compromise order application will be delayed until the application fully complies with the governing statutory and regulatory requirements.

View ruleSource: page 4, section Infant Compromise Orders

What must be included with ex parte infant compromise order application filings before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

When an action has already been initiated, the infant compromise order application should be filed ex parte on NYSCEF with the specified label.

View ruleSource: page 4, section Infant Compromise Orders

How may parties contact Judge Mary Ann Brigantti's chambers?

The court does not accept ex parte communications.

View ruleSource: page 1, section I. GENERAL RULES — Communications with Chambers

How does Judge Mary Ann Brigantti handle sealed or redacted filings?

Process: file redacted on ecf. The infant’s full name and full date of birth, rather than initials and year alone, must be redacted in every electronically filed document.

View ruleSource: page 4, section Infant Compromise Orders

How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

Conference adjournments will not be granted unless the requesting party shows good cause.

View ruleSource: page 4, section Pre-Trial Conference

Is electronic filing required before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

Fax submissions must comply with section 202.5 and may not be sent to the court without the Part's advance approval.

View ruleSource: page 2, section I. GENERAL RULES — Electronic Submission of Papers

Are filing fees or waivers addressed before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

A fee is required for covered filings. The party filing the first paper must pay the proper fee, obtain an index number from the county clerk, and affix it to the paper.

View ruleSource: page 2, section I. GENERAL RULES — Form of Papers

What filing deadlines does Judge Mary Ann Brigantti set?

A CPLR 3212(a) summary-judgment motion ordinarily must be filed no later than 60 days after the note of issue is filed, unless the court grants leave for good cause.

View ruleSource: page 9, section 4. Summary Judgment Motions

What rule applies to service for notice of appearance before Judge Mary Ann Brigantti?

Details: recipient: all parties. Each attorney notified of a scheduled appearance must notify all other parties by email of the assigned date and time.

View ruleSource: page 3, section Remote appearances via Microsoft Teams
Complete rules summary for Judge Mary Ann Brigantti

Every filed paper must have margins of at least one inch.

Conference adjournments will not be granted unless the requesting party shows good cause.

Approval of an infant compromise order application will be delayed until the application fully complies with the governing statutory and regulatory requirements.

The court does not accept ex parte communications.

Telephone calls to Chambers are permitted only for emergencies requiring immediate attention.

Fax submissions must comply with section 202.5 and may not be sent to the court without the Part's advance approval.

Letters and emails sent to the court must copy all parties and must be e-filed when applicable.

Each cover and first page must state the county of venue and describe the paper; if an individual judge is assigned, the assigned judge's name must also appear to the right of the caption.

Attorneys and pro se parties must check in with the Part Clerk when entering the courtroom.

A party leaving the courtroom must provide current contact information, including a cell phone number, on the outside calendar or with the clerk.

Counsel, including self-represented litigants, must promptly notify the court of settlement, discontinuance, disposition, mootness, death, or bankruptcy.

Counsel must immediately notify the assigned judge or court part and Chambers by submitting the stipulation or a letter to the part clerk and sending notice by email when an action is settled, discontinued, or otherwise disposed of.

The party filing the first paper must promptly communicate the county clerk's index number in writing to all other parties.

The party filing the first paper must pay the proper fee, obtain an index number from the county clerk, and affix it to the paper.

Fax or electronic submissions ordinarily should not be followed by a hard copy unless the court requests one.

After the first filing, the index number must appear on the outside cover and first page to the right of the caption of every paper tendered for filing.

In the court's discretion, counsel maybe requested to submit memoranda of law by e-mail or by other electronic means, such as by a computer flash drive, along with an original and courtesy copy.

Every paper filed in court must include appropriate proof of service on all parties when service is required.

Typewritten papers must use at least double spacing between lines, except for quotations and attorney names and addresses.

Footnotes must be printed in no smaller than 10-point type.

Except for exhibits and printed forms, filed papers must be written on one side only, although side-fastened papers may be written on both sides.

Electronically submitted memoranda of law, affidavits, and affirmations exceeding 4,500 words must include bookmarks listing the contents and facilitating navigation.

Case and calendar status inquiries should initially be directed to the IAS Motion Support Office in Room 217.

Each attorney notified of a scheduled appearance must notify all other parties by email of the assigned date and time.

Decisions and orders are available online through NYSCEF or the Bronx County Clerk, and telephone inquiries about whether a decision has issued are prohibited.

A settlement-conference request supported by a stipulation signed by all parties must be emailed to the listed addresses and filed by letter on NYSCEF.

An adjournment request for a remote conference must be written, transmitted to the court and all parties at least 48 hours beforehand, and state whether the other parties consent.

When an action has already been initiated, the infant compromise order application should be filed ex parte on NYSCEF with the specified label.

The infant’s full name and full date of birth, rather than initials and year alone, must be redacted in every electronically filed document.

Counsel and unrepresented litigants must use the Infant Compromise Order checklist before submitting a proposed ICO.

More Judges in New York Supreme Court, Bronx County

Alicia Gerez
Judge
Alison Tuitt
Judge
Andrew J. Cohen
Judge
Ben Barbato
Judge
Bianka Perez
Judge
Edit Shkreli
Judge
Elizabeth Taylor
Judge
Erik L. Gray
Judge