New: a trial court in 1 of every 10 U.S. counties. Read the post
Court Rules
Judge

Judge Panteha E. Saban

Individual Rules, Standing Orders & Policies

Santa Clara Superior Court

Limits & Logistics

Document Limits

BriefCourt-wide
6 pgs
Evidentiary AttachmentsCourt-wide
10 pgs
Documents Submitted to EvaluatorCourt-wide
15 pgs
Mandatory Settlement Conference StatementCourt-wide
5 pgs
Attachment to PleadingCourt-wide
10 pgs
Memorandum of Points and AuthoritiesCourt-wide
25 pgs

Courtesy Copies

Courtesy copies

  • 1 copy • Email
  • Email

Final Instructions

  • 16 copies

Any Document Offered at Hearing

Court-wide
  • 3 copies • At Hearing

Application or Motion, Proposed Settled Statement, Response

Court-wide

Adjournments

Court-wide
2Court Daysnotice
Adversary Position

Request must include

Reason for RequestAdversary PositionProposed Rescheduled DateOriginal DateNumber of Previous RequestsPrevious Requests Granted or Denied
1Court Daysnotice
10Calendar Daysnotice
Reason for Request
3Court Daysnotice
48Hoursnotice
Filters:

Document Format Requirements1 rule

FormattingImportantCivil cases

Counsel shall provide the courtroom clerk with an Exhibit List in an editable Word version.

File type
Word
Applies to
  • Exhibit list
dept-3-ctj · p. 8
|SectionExhibits (All Trials)

Document Filing Requirements5 rules

Filing RequirementsImportantCivil cases

Any non-CACI or pinpoint instructions shall be submitted in writing.

dept-3-ctj · p. 5
|SectionJury Instructions (Jury Trials)
Filing RequirementsImportantCivil cases

Exhibit lists must identify each proffered exhibit with a specific description of its substance, not a general description.

Court's wording

For all trials, on the respective exhibit lists, please provide specific descriptions to briefly 12 identify the substance of each proffered exhibit. General descriptions such as "Documents produced by opponent in discovery," etc., are not sufficiently

dept-3-ctj · p. 8
|SectionExhibits (All Trials)
Filing RequirementsNoteCivil cases

If the parties cannot agree, they will submit plaintiffs' proposal red-lined against defendants' proposal. On even numbered calendar days, plaintiffs will be responsible for the submission. On odd numbered calendar days, defendants will be responsible for the submission.

dept-3-ctj · p. 3
|SectionCourt Reporters
Filing RequirementsNoteCivil cases

matters. Counsels shall 12 meet and confer in advance of the start of trial regarding factual stipulations on uncontroverted matters and place such stipulations

dept-3-ctj · p. 4
|SectionPretrial Submissions and Conference
Filing RequirementsNoteCivil cases

However, retrieving, copying, and circulating completed questionnaires to all counsel and to the Court before voir dire begins will be the responsibility of Counsel.

dept-3-ctj · p. 4
|SectionJury Trials

Filing & Service rules

Filing Timing and Cure Windows

Counsel in jury trials must provide the Court with complete hard copies of specified pretrial documents (in limine motions, exhibit/witness lists, jury instructions, verdict forms, stipulations, statement of the case, trial briefs, voir dire questions/questionnaires) by 12:00 pm on the last court day before trial.

Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, counsel in jury trials shall provide the Court with complete hard copy the following by 12:00 pm on the last court day before the date set for 16 trial: all in limine motions; exhibit lists, except impeachment exhibits; witness lists, except 17 impeachment witnesses; jury instruction requests (see further discussion below); proposed verdict forms; any stipulations on factual or legal issues; a statement of the case; trial briefs; and 18 any proposed special jury voir dire questions or

Civil cases

Page 4 | Jury Trials

In bench trials, counsel must provide the Court with hard copies of specified pretrial documents by 12:00 pm on the last court day before trial.

Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, counsel in bench trials shall provide the Court with 3 complete hard copy of the following by 12:00 pm on the last court day before the date set for trial: all in limine motions; exhibit lists, except impeachment exhibits; witness lists, except 4 impeachment witnesses; any stipulations on factual or legal issues; statement of the case; and

Civil cases

Page 5 | Bench Trials

A list of requested CACI jury instructions must be submitted to the Court by 12:00 pm the day before trial.

A list of requested jury instructions (CACI) shall be submitted to the Court by 12:00 pm the day before the day set for trial.

Civil cases

Page 5 | Jury Instructions (Jury Trials)

Originals of all depositions that may be used at trial must be lodged with the Clerk before trial begins.

Originals of all depositions that may be used during trial are to be lodged with the Clerk 12 before trial

Civil cases

Page 5 | All Trials

If no court reporter is retained, counsel must meet and confer at the end of each trial day and file the settled statement in court the following day at or before 8:45 a.m.

court reporter is not retained, the court will order counsel to meet and confer at the end of each trial day to agree on a settled statement. The settled statement will be filed in court 28 the following day at or before 8:45 a.m. If

Civil cases

Page 3 | Court Reporters

An edited set of instructions shall be submitted at the earliest 18 possible time after the conclusion of in limine motions if

An edited set of instructions shall be submitted at the earliest 18 possible time after the conclusion of in limine motions if

Civil cases

Page 5 | Jury Instructions (Jury Trials)

The prevailing party must prepare and submit the judgment within 5 court days after the trial concludes.

a verdict is rendered by the jury, the prevailing party shall prepare the judgment, unless otherwise directed by the Court. The judgment shall be submitted within 5 court days after 26 the trial is concluded.

Civil cases

Page 9 | After Trial

Courtesy Copy Requirements

Email a courtesy copy of all e-filed documents to the court at department3@scscourt.org, cc'ing all counsel.

Please email a courtesy copy of all e-filed documents to the court (cc’ing all counsel). The department email is: department3@scscourt.org

Civil cases

Page 4 | Jury Trials

Counsel must provide 16-17 copies of the final jury instructions to the Court (12 for jury, 2-3 for alternates, a courtesy copy for the judge, and a copy to be filed); each side should also have its own copy.

Counsel are responsible for providing 16-17 copies (12 for jury, 2-3 for alternates, courtesy copy for judge to read and a copy to be filed) of the final instructions to 21 Court and each side should have their own

Civil cases

Page 5 | Jury Instructions (Jury Trials)

An email courtesy copy of all e-filed documents must be sent to the Court, with all counsel copied.

Please email a courtesy copy of all e-filed documents to the court (cc’ing all counsel). The

Civil cases

Page 5 | Bench Trials

Chambers Communication Rules

Attorneys must contact Department 3 by email (monitored 8:30 a.m.–4:30 p.m.), must not contact the Judge directly without permission, and should copy other parties to avoid ex parte communication.

Attorneys shall contact D3 by email at Department3@scscourt.org. This email is monitored by 18 the courtroom clerk between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. Attorneys shall not contact the Judge directly without express permission.. To avoid ex parte communication, please also 19 copy the other party/parties on

Civil cases

Page 3 | Contact

The department email for the Court is department3@scscourt.org.

The department email is: department3@scscourt.org

Civil cases

Page 5 | Bench Trials

Court-wide rules

Applies court-wide

These 1330 rules apply across Santa Clara Superior Court. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.

Filing Requirements

All 548
  • The Court will not approve the Settlement Administrator's costs award until the final approval hearing, when admissible evidence supporting the request must be provided.

  • Applies to
    Stipulations

    Counsel must confer before trial, attempt to stipulate, and reduce all stipulations to writing; written stipulations are filed and read aloud into the record during jury trials.

  • Applies to
    Settlement conference statement

    Each party must file a Settlement Conference Statement at least 10 calendar days before the MSC, or 15 calendar days if service is by mail.

Service

All 202
  • Applies to
    Application

    The moving party must send a copy of the application to FCS.

  • The party requesting criminal protective order modification must serve the Request on all parties and agencies, including the District Attorney, Adult Probation (if applicable), the accused, and the accused's attorney, at least five days before the hearing.

  • Service
    Electronic service to all parties

    All represented parties must electronically send all briefs, motions in limine, and witness lists to all parties.

Filing Timing

All 177
  • Drop box filings are checked once per court day at 4:00 p.m. and deemed received at that time on retrieval day.

  • Deadline
    10 calendar days

    The Court must set a review hearing within 94 calendar days of appointment; if no written objections are received within 10 calendar days before the hearing, no appearance is necessary.

  • Deadline
    94 calendar days

    The Court will set a compliance review approximately 94 calendar days after appointment to confirm the Inventory and Appraisal and Notice have been filed and served.

E-Filing

All 77
  • Parties filing electronically must use one of the court's approved electronic filing service providers, with procedures available on the court's website.

  • Applies to
    Adr stipulation and order form

    Unless the parties otherwise agree, the plaintiff is responsible for e-filing the ADR stipulation and order.

  • Applies to
    Application and order

    DFCS must e-file an Application and Order requesting the court order the child returned to the parent on a Family Maintenance plan.

About Judge Panteha E. Saban

Panteha E. Saban is a judge of the Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara, presiding over Department 3. The court is the state trial court for Santa Clara County, handling civil, criminal, and other trial matters.

Practitioners will find the procedures for Department 3 in the document dept-3-ctj.pdf.

Common questions about Judge Panteha E. Saban's rules

Are courtesy copies required for Judge Panteha E. Saban?

Details: by email. An email courtesy copy of all e-filed documents must be sent to the Court, with all counsel copied.

View ruleSource: page 5, section Bench Trials

What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Panteha E. Saban?

Judge Panteha E. Saban's formatting rule includes file format docx. Counsel must give the courtroom clerk an editable Word version of the Exhibit List.

View ruleSource: page 8, section Exhibits (All Trials)

What must be included with non caci instruction filings before Judge Panteha E. Saban?

Any non-CACI or pinpoint instructions must be submitted in writing.

View ruleSource: page 5, section Jury Instructions (Jury Trials)

What must be included with exhibit list filings before Judge Panteha E. Saban?

Exhibit lists must identify each proffered exhibit with a specific description of its substance, not a general description.

View ruleSource: page 8, section Exhibits (All Trials)

How may parties contact Judge Panteha E. Saban's chambers?

The rule lists email Department3@scscourt.org. Attorneys must contact Department 3 by email (monitored 8:30 a.m.–4:30 p.m.), must not contact the Judge directly without permission, and should copy other parties to avoid ex parte communication.

View ruleSource: page 3, section Contact

When is a filing treated as filed before Judge Panteha E. Saban?

The rule states a 12:00 PM filing cutoff. A list of requested CACI jury instructions must be submitted to the Court by 12:00 pm the day before trial.

View ruleSource: page 5, section Jury Instructions (Jury Trials)
Complete rules summary for Judge Panteha E. Saban

Attorneys must contact Department 3 by email (monitored 8:30 a.m.–4:30 p.m.), must not contact the Judge directly without permission, and should copy other parties to avoid ex parte communication.

If no court reporter is retained, counsel must meet and confer at the end of each trial day and file the settled statement in court the following day at or before 8:45 a.m.

If the parties cannot agree on a settled statement, they submit plaintiffs' proposal red-lined against defendants' proposal, with plaintiffs responsible on even-numbered calendar days and defendants on odd-numbered days.

Counsel is responsible for retrieving, copying, and circulating completed jury questionnaires to all counsel and the Court before voir dire begins.

An email courtesy copy of all e-filed documents must be sent to the Court, with all counsel copied.

The department email for the Court is department3@scscourt.org.

Email a courtesy copy of all e-filed documents to the court at department3@scscourt.org, cc'ing all counsel.

A list of requested CACI jury instructions must be submitted to the Court by 12:00 pm the day before trial.

Any non-CACI or pinpoint instructions must be submitted in writing.

Counsel must provide 16-17 copies of the final jury instructions to the Court (12 for jury, 2-3 for alternates, a courtesy copy for the judge, and a copy to be filed); each side should also have its own copy.

Exhibit lists must identify each proffered exhibit with a specific description of its substance, not a general description.

Counsel must give the courtroom clerk an editable Word version of the Exhibit List.

In bench trials, counsel must provide the Court with hard copies of specified pretrial documents by 12:00 pm on the last court day before trial.

An edited set of instructions shall be submitted at the earliest 18 possible time after the conclusion of in limine motions if

Counsel must meet and confer before trial on factual stipulations for uncontroverted matters and place those stipulations in writing.

The prevailing party must prepare and submit the judgment within 5 court days after the trial concludes.

Counsel in jury trials must provide the Court with complete hard copies of specified pretrial documents (in limine motions, exhibit/witness lists, jury instructions, verdict forms, stipulations, statement of the case, trial briefs, voir dire questions/questionnaires) by 12:00 pm on the last court day before trial.

Originals of all depositions that may be used at trial must be lodged with the Clerk before trial begins.

More Judges in Santa Clara Superior Court

Amber Rosen
Judge
Audra Ibarra
Judge
Benjamin Williams
Judge
Beth McGowen
Judge
Brian J. Buckelew
Judge
Brooke A. Blecher
Judge
Carl Chamberlin
Judge
Christine Copeland
Judge